Re:Python’s lambda is broken
by enum on Thursday April 09, 2009 @01:11PM
(#554710)
Lambda is fine. The loops are mutating the variable i, so all the lambda share the same i. Apparently, list comprehensions also use mutation--I suppose that's fine.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Indeed, Python is using lexical scoping. This behavior is well known.
While true, that is not really the issue. The issue is which lexical scope the loop iterator is defined in. In python, it is apparently like this:
i = 0
increment i
<do loop body with i>
It could have been: i = 0
increment 1
create new environment
bind i here
<do loop body>
In the second case, each loop body would have its own "i". In the first case, they all share the same "i".