Re:Anonymous Open Letter to the Ember.js Core Team
by tlrobinson on Saturday April 13, 2013 @04:05PM
(#5544472)
Maybe the open source community needs a sort of standard way of declaring/disclaiming how production-ready a project is, and how much effort we intend to put into supporting it.
Re:Anonymous Open Letter to the Ember.js Core Team
by jamesbritt on Saturday April 13, 2013 @04:34PM
(#5544581)
People should assume that if there is no affirmative declaration of "This is production ready" then the code is not production ready.
If there is no affirmative declaration of "I will be actively supporting this beyond my own personal needs" then assume that the code will not be supported beyond the personal needs of the project owner.
Or people can just ask, instead complaining (however well-intended) that their assumptions have turned out false.
This is like people who build a business on some aspect of Twitter or Facebook then complain that Twitter or Facebook is shutting them out. If you are using someone else's code or API make sure you get some positive, unambiguous statement from the owner about what to expect.
Things can still go south, but then you at least have a legitimate gripe.
Re:Anonymous Open Letter to the Ember.js Core Team
by steveklabnik on Saturday April 13, 2013 @04:56PM
(#5544648)
In the gist, even though the Ember Data README states that it's not production ready, the author complains that it 'should be' or something. We have that standard, it's called '1.0'.
(Both the open letter and the response from Tom Dale seem to acknowledge that there's two sides to this issue, which is refreshing. Usually you get these really boorish "dude, it's open source, just fix it yourself will ya" responses.)
It makes me wary of pushing any of my projects. I still open source pretty much everything I do, but usually with a big fat "for your edification, don't expect any support or ongoing development" disclaimer.
(Also see fat's "What Is Open Source & Why Do I Feel So Guilty? at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIDb6VBO9os)