News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by vacri on Friday April 12, 2013 @01:16AM (#5536778)
Yeah, it's hardly a broken system just because you want to make money from the cool riffs that other people came up with, all without paying them a cent.

If you're sampling someone else, then you're effectively making them a co-author of your material - and they should be due royalties for that, just like if you covered their song. How many mixes have we heard where the signature is the sample and the chaff is the stuff surrounding it?

In any case, if the samples really were trivial and not worth kicking back money... then they wouldn't be sampled in the first place :)

Re:The Economics Of Girl Talk by anigbrowl on Friday April 12, 2013 @02:31AM (#5536974)
How many mixes have we heard where the signature is the sample and the chaff is the stuff surrounding it?

That's a great point. One song the article mentioned that epitomized this was the Puff Daddy 'Missing you' song. The sentiment was worthwhile, and I can also see it within the musical tradition of rap and the soundsystem aesthetic where musicians develop their MCing skills by rapping over over a sampled loop in their bedroom/the garage etc. so to build a whole song over a single looped sample with a minimum of additional production elements actually served a musical function of evoking nostalgia for 'the way things used to be' when the people in question were young and just learning how to rap. But it ended up sounding like a complete lift of someone else's song, and while the licensing was probably taken care of in this case it's spawned thousands of imitations with even less musical novelty.