Re:Ask HN: Have you created alternate accounts to post quest...
by makecheck on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @04:18PM
(#553359)
I have just one account.
For me, it boils down to this: a goal of the site is to improve quality of discussion.
There are two main parties to discussion: "you", and "everyone else".
When "you" post: if you already suspect that your topic will earn down-votes, then why post it (from any account)? Apparently the topic is not something interesting to this group.
When "everyone else" down-votes: they have a responsibility to be smart, and not childish. It's shallow to click the down-arrow simply for disagreeing with somebody or not liking them personally. If there is a general feeling that down-votes are always for legitimate reason, I think people would be less likely to "hide" behind anonymous accounts.
For me, it boils down to this: a goal of the site is to improve quality of discussion.
There are two main parties to discussion: "you", and "everyone else".
When "you" post: if you already suspect that your topic will earn down-votes, then why post it (from any account)? Apparently the topic is not something interesting to this group.
When "everyone else" down-votes: they have a responsibility to be smart, and not childish. It's shallow to click the down-arrow simply for disagreeing with somebody or not liking them personally. If there is a general feeling that down-votes are always for legitimate reason, I think people would be less likely to "hide" behind anonymous accounts.