That said, this round does make a lot of sense for investors and management. If they didn't raise a round they would have run out of cash. That's over 5 years and $100M down the drain today. Rather than write the entire thing off, they're giving the company another 2 years to create something worth more than bankruptcy. There is still a lot to bet on. I'm not sure where they'll concentrate, but there is something valuable in being the location based layer of the internet, or being in a position to make cities more searchable on the go.
Notice it's a debt round (w no valuation). They aren't trying to value the company higher, they're just trying to keep it alive as cheaply as possible
I'm not questioning the decision on the Foursquare side anyway, although they are clearly avoiding releasing any data that would give people an understanding of the current state of the company. I question the decision on the part of the investors. This is a lot of money to put in, and for what? The best case might be a 2x-3x return, but in my opinion the median return on this is $0, all the money spent and virtually no value in the end.
I would imagine it's very hard for the management of FourSquare to let go emotionally, especially after hopes ran high in 2009/2010 and they had huge growth. It's clear that that growth has ended, and that they are now in a period of declining use. Combine that with an inability to monazite the existing user base and I see absolutely no hope of success.
I suppose they could pivot the company, but why would they do that? It would make far more sense to leave FourSquare and build a new company that didn't have all of FourSquare's baggage and dilution from investments in the old model.
When something doesn't make sense many times I have found that there is probably something about it that is not known. Either something in the pipeline, or is a candidate to be acquired and they need to keep it alive a bit longer to make that happen.
I wrote a sizable piece on the future of Foursquare and monetization today here. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5533949
The title of the press release is "Continuing Foursquare’s Growth"! Growth is obviously what they want to make you think is happening, unfortunately they have no growth to show.
http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=foursquare%2C%20pinte...
Foursquare has no growth since 2011 and no way to generate significant revenue. If the numbers they quote on the press release are true, they would have so much cash rolling in that they would laugh at the idea of raising more money. The press release is intentionally misleading; this company is dying.