News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by megaman821 on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:48AM (#5531556)
These assessments don't mean much because we are only getting one side of the story. Let's measure electricity from the power plant to the car and compare it to gas from the gas station to the car. How did gas magically appear at the gas station? Do oil pumps, oil tankers, refineries, delivery vehicles, and gas stations themselves now produce no pollution and waste?
Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by nekopa on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:04AM (#5531641)
In the article they said the study included 'well to wheels' in their calculations, so it's not just one side of the story, they factored in all you're talking about.
Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by megaman821 on Thursday April 11, 2013 @12:58PM (#5533195)
The briefly mention it in the parent article and found electric vehicles to be more efficient. Then they throw in lithium battery production which is probably the least efficient step of the electric vehicle ecosystem. Why not throw in oil pipeline construction impact vs electric grid construction or waste by-products of a coal plant or wind farm vs a crude oil refinery?
Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by waps on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:55AM (#5531950)
The problem is the true answer to light environmental impact does not fit very well in either side's political ideology.

Pick whatever mode of transportation that costs the least, and the chance is very good that it's environmental impact is also the least of the available options. This provides a good rule of thumb. A small gasoline car (there are no small electrical cars) will easily win out over all alternatives, in some cases even over public transport.

Even human power (ie. bikes, walking) is not as green as you'd think. Humans eat expensive multiple times reprocessed food. Especially meat is expensive. And moving does actually cost energy. I wonder if anyone's ever done a rigorous calculation of that. I did some back of the envelope calculations, and knowing that a trained athlete's body can approach efficiencies of 25% in some cases (normal people, 10% at best), and that food has to be transported > 100km on average, I found walking/biking is only barely more environmentally friendly than an efficient, small car (assuming equivalent distance, of course, and assuming 5liters/100km). Using energy gained from eating meat to walk is very likely to be less efficient than driving (yet that's exactly what athletes do, although they have their increased efficiency).

Of course that's not to say walking/running/biking doesn't have other advantages. But humans burn fuel to produce co2 + work just as cars do, it's just much less visible.

Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by jsingleton on Thursday April 11, 2013 @10:23AM (#5532109)
If you're interested in these sorts of calculations then I can recommend this book: http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Bad-Are-Bananas-everything/dp/18...

I found it a really good read and to geek it off it's written by the brother of the inventor of the web.

Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by notdonspaulding on Thursday April 11, 2013 @10:35AM (#5532184)
Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by waps on Thursday April 11, 2013 @11:30AM (#5532579)
Heh, so there are. I've never seen those before, outside from special test installations. I didn't think they were even cleared for public roads.

Thanks, interesting links. I can't seem to find a locations where I could buy one of those though.

Re:What's the real environmental cost of electric cars? by deelowe on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:54AM (#5531945)
I'm not sure you read the article. They compared both from the source to the wheels.