News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by jrockway on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:32AM (#552745)
I don't understand people's obsessions with version numbers.

When I release a project, I start at 0.01, then release 0.02, and so on. The version numbers mean nothing to me, other than that they are increasing.

I still have people email me, though, and say things like, "I saw your project Foo::Bar, when do you think it will be 1.0?" I don't really know what to say...

Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by scott_s on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:49AM (#552767)
Because version numbers are an implicit signal of maturity. The convention is that a 1.0 software release is complete. It's understood that it's not the final release, and it may still contain bugs, but it's a common signal to indicate "This is the first version of my software I feel is complete enough that I'm comfortable releasing in the wild."

Some applications have their own numbering conventions to indicate what kind of an update a new version is. If you're familiar with the software, it's useful to know at a glance what to expect. (The Linux kernel and gcc do this.)

You can ignore this convention, but you're going to encounter confusion from potential users.

Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by nostrademons on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @12:43PM (#552961)
Yet there's crazyness like Sun renaming Java 1.5 to Java 5, or Python 3 to Python 3000, or Netscape 4.7 to Netscape 6.0. Many of these are explicitly for marketing purposes, because a competitor had a higher version number.

It's moronic to compare version numbers across products precisely because standards vary so widely. I'd say that Django 0.97 was more stable than Rails 2.0, yet it's not even a 1.0!

Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by FalconNL on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @10:48AM (#552765)
Not so much obsession as convention. Generally versions 0.x - 1.0 are the alpha and beta releases, with 1.0 being the first "stable" release. Obviously there are hundreds of projects that follow a different schema, but it's used enough that it has stuck. One solution if you want to keep your versioning style would be to annotate them as stable or development, possibly with a short paragraph explaining that version 0.0.3 is in fact bugfree/feature-complete/ready for use in production/etc.
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by GavinB on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:33AM (#552837)
If you care so little about version numbers, why do you start at 0.01? Why not just start at 1 and save yourself the three characters?
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by eru on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:49AM (#552863)
Or start at 0 --- for geek cred.
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by jrockway on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @11:44AM (#552855)
Convention.
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by kirubakaran on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @12:56PM (#552984)
However you don't like convention when it comes to what 1.0 means?
Re:Why Is Gmail Still in Beta? by jrockway on Wednesday April 08, 2009 @03:47PM (#553312)
I don't like the convention where I have to decide whether or not something I write is suitable for other people. They should read the code and decide for themselves.