Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by FireBeyond on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @11:19PM
(#5523022)
Exactly. As annoying as it is, this isn't a breach of DMCA in any way, shape or form - it's YouTube saying "it's more important for us to make the record labels happier than it is you". And, for better or worse, that's their perfect right.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @01:39AM
(#5523407)
* cue someone arguing that YouTube can't do that, because it's a violation of the First Amendment
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:46AM
(#5523585)
It's not. The First Amendment guarantees you a voice, but not an audience. Youtube has every right to tell you to sod off if they don't like your content for any reason.
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:55AM
(#5523617)
Of course it isn't. YouTube isn't the government, so it doesn't even apply. My comment was poking fun at people who forget about that.
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by AgentConundrum on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:54AM
(#5523788)
FWIW, I upvoted you back into the black, since I thought your intention was clear. Lots of people seem to make this mistake, that somehow the first amendment means that private companies aren't allowed to censor you.
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by sageikosa on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:20AM
(#5524915)
Technically, they are not censoring you, they just aren't providing you a free podium.
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by hawleyal on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:10AM
(#5524851)
Just because they can legally, doesn't mean their not douchebags for doing it.
If yours is the only press, it makes your level of shenanigans worse.
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by FireBeyond on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:53PM
(#5527651)
Because YouTube is the only video sharing site on the internet?
Because you are not permitted to run your own web site / server to share your videos?
Do YouTube have a legal, moral or ethical obligation to you to allow you access to their ecosystems for your benefit?
Re:You Can't Stop Universal From Removing Your YouTube Videos
by hawleyal on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:35PM
(#5527971)
It would be disingenuous to suggest YouTube is not the de facto video sharing site. If they censor something, it's a big deal.
It's the same thing with Amazon, Google, Twitter, or iOS. There are ethical implications if you are one of the major conduits by which people communicate and disseminate information, regardless of your status as a private or public utility.
Legal? Who cares. Ethical? Maybe. A good idea? No.
You think Twitter doesn't feel responsibility if they close out an entire country from their service?
You are pretending there are lines dividing sides that are black and white.