That was roughly my take away. Hetzner looks really bad - but the explanation that they are incompetent and lazy sounds more likely than the criminal explanation.
And EFnet looks wronged. But also looks bad for spreading allegations against Hetzner of profiteering from criminals without much more substantial backing.
Sticking to the facts of the situation would have produced a more powerful, and damning condemnation.
This isn't court, I think it's reasonable to forgive humanity entering into the issue. Besides, this appears to be a citizenship issue, so banishment also comes as no surprise.
Re:Efnet klines all Hetzner netblocks
by devicenull on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:53PM
(#5519791)
What are "best practices" here? I've been unable to find any guidance about how these types of issues should be handled.
I don't think that this has to do with Hetzner needing criminal business but rather with Hetzner not wanting to shut down an entire server if a part of it has been breached. Forwarding that complaint in it's entirety is definitely not best practice however making such allegations is neither.