>>>If you look at my HN submissions over the last half decade
Who does that? Does anyone? Don't take an objection personally. It's all about the ideas here.
Re:IT for Oppression
by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @08:48AM
(#5517674)
I think the parent was trying to say "I have been a supporter of Schneier and I have a track record (should anyone care to look) to demonstrate that"
I doubt he is expecting you to review his comments pages. Probably full of typos anyway :-)
I believe part of the reason for his approach is for the sake of maintaining a strong defensive posture. For example, as the person who coined the phrase "Security Theater" in regards to the DHS airport screening, he did a great job of illuminating the problems. On the other hand, if he had proposed a solution, then he would have left himself open to criticism from political pundits. If he had stood up and said, "Abolish the DHS," then many would portray him as a kook and many would have written off his views.
What he does is clever, but I'm uncertain how effective it is. Citing the research/proposals of others, without endorsement, would allow people to also see potential/proposed solutions, as well as see the problems.