Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere...
by cheald on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:54PM
(#5514088)
I think it's a pretty clear solution to the problem, honestly. Broadcasting is very clearly defined, and Aereo is very clearly unicasting.
If Aereo was using a single antenna and capturing the source to send to multiple clients, they'd be broadcasting:
*===\
*===A===S
*===/
But instead, they're providing a 1:1 receive-and-transmit, basically turning them into a DVR with a really long cable:
*===A===\
*===A====S
*===A===/
I think it was really the right ruling. The stations are upset that Aereo is capitalizing on their content, but what Aereo is selling is a DVR, not their content. They aren't broadcasting by any means.
If Aereo was using a single antenna and capturing the source to send to multiple clients, they'd be broadcasting:
But instead, they're providing a 1:1 receive-and-transmit, basically turning them into a DVR with a really long cable: I think it was really the right ruling. The stations are upset that Aereo is capitalizing on their content, but what Aereo is selling is a DVR, not their content. They aren't broadcasting by any means.