News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:42PM (#5514017)
So, basically, the entire broadcast television industry is built on a wishy-washy technicality in a court ruling, that's just begging to be hacked?
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:55PM (#5514098)
It's not really a technicality. The business model is such:

1) The broadcast networks distribute content freely over the airwaves. 2) The broadcast networks also sell that content to cable networks who then retransmit it.

Forget the law. Is it reasonable for the cable networks to just capture the over-the-air stream and retransmit? I think you can argue both sides. On one hand, there is a public benefit to free over the air TV, but that specific benefit is not served when a for-profit cable provider retransmits that content to paying cable customers. On the other hand, how do you distinguish in a principled way the spectrum between an individual receiving the content with his antenna and what Time Warner Cable might do, with services like Aereo in the middle?

I know we're all about advertising these days, but it's not an unreasonable business model to produce content, then sell that content to distributors who in turn distribute it to paying customers.

It might, however, be unreasonable to be able to expect to do this while also cashing in on advertising revenue by freely broadcasting that same content over the air.

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:17PM (#5514675)
Maybe technicality is the wrong word, but their business is built on the court's decision of what constitutes redistribution. Such a decision is open to 1) reinterpretation and 2) gaming. It just feels... like a rather brittle business model. Their major customers (cable companies) are only working with them out of the force of law.

It's hard to argue against the business model as it's been stunningly successful, I'm just surprised it's taken this long to be disrupted.

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:51PM (#5514881)
The business model is brittle in the sense of trying to capitalize both on free unencrypted OTA and also cable retransmission, no doubt. But either business model by itself is quite reasonable.
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by MatthewPhillips on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:55PM (#5514899)
So you disagree that it's brittle to base on a business model on a court ruling? That is, to repeat myself, open to reinterpretation/challenges and open to gaming (as Aereo is doing now)?
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:40PM (#5515154)
I misunderstood you. I thought you were talking about the broadcasters, not Aereo. But yeah, companies built business models on court rulings (e.g. Sony VCR's).
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by larrys on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:46PM (#5514467)
"On the other hand, how do you distinguish in a principled way the spectrum between an individual receiving the content with his antenna and what Time Warner Cable might do, with services like Aereo in the middle?"

Isn't this a bit like asking why I can read something from a particular website online for free but someone can't take that free content and have me read it in it's entirety on another website? (Or am I misunderstanding the point you are making?)

One point though regardless that matters is that is that if I have a service that I charge money for and I use your product to provide value to my customers (even for free) shouldn't you be compensated for that even if those customers could have gotten the same content another way?

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by AnthonyMouse on Monday April 08, 2013 @06:11PM (#5515003)
>Isn't this a bit like asking why I can read something from a particular website online for free but someone can't take that free content and have me read it in it's entirety on another website? (Or am I misunderstanding the point you are making?)

It is kind of the same thing -- but it has the same issue. Suppose I set up a public proxy server, or a Tor exit node, or a service like AWS that anyone can route traffic through. Now all the content on "your" website is available through "my" server. Do you suppose that to be unreasonable? That's pretty much what Aereo is doing with broadcasts, isn't it?

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by rayiner on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:52PM (#5514510)
> Isn't this a bit like asking why I can read something from a particular website online for free but someone can't take that free content and have me read it in it's entirety on another website? (Or am I misunderstanding the point you are making?)

It's a lot like that, except with the angle of: what does that mean for a company like Aereo, which ostensibly just offers you a "really big antenna" to watch the broadcasters' content?

The problem seems to be that you (some people) want to give some leeway to companies like Aereo to do space shifting of broadcast content, without having to say "okay cable providers, you don't have to pay for anything you can capture on the air."

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by caf on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @05:44AM (#5517140)
One point though regardless that matters is that is that if I have a service that I charge money for and I use your product to provide value to my customers (even for free) shouldn't you be compensated for that even if those customers could have gotten the same content another way?

Isn't this what every ISP is doing with the content of every website in the world?

What about TV antenna installers - their product is virtually useless without all that broadcast content that they don't compensate the producers for?

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by dsr_ on Monday April 08, 2013 @03:54PM (#5514087)
No, the cable industry is built on the technicality.

Broadcasters have the right to negotiate with cable companies for carriage. http://www.fcc.gov/guides/cable-carriage-broadcast-stations

They either have the right to demand that they be carried (in which case it is for free) or to demand that they be compensated (in which case the cable company does not have to carry them).

Every three years they get to re-decide. Without either the must-carry notification or the negotiated contract, cable companies can't carry them.

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by sjs382 on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:14PM (#5514235)
Where can I learn more about the first scenario that you mention? (demanding that cable companies carry your broadcast)

What are the limits on this? Can an individual set up a low powered broadcast station and force the cable company to carry it?

Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by dsr_ on Monday April 08, 2013 @05:22PM (#5514707)
See the comment below about rarity for individuals, but note that basically every town or city has the power to write a similar compulsion to force a cable company to carry a community access station as a price for operation. If all you want is to get some airtime for a non-commercial message, you can probably go to a community access channel for free.
Re:News Corp. Threatens to Pull Fox Off the Airwaves If Aere... by VLM on Monday April 08, 2013 @04:29PM (#5514343)
You would have to be a rather rich individual in an unusual locale to license a new TV station in an area developed enough to have a cable company, but undeveloped enough to convince the FCC to issue the license without interference with existing stations. This is not a "new tech startup" model, at least not now. The goldrush was over about a quarter century ago.