Re:Lisp's reputation is so bad that many people don't even t...
by 10ren on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @01:52PM
(#551331)
Yes, I can see parentheses as a convenient catch-phrase. While it's less familiar than indentation in Python, you're right that people complain about that too, but it hasn't stopped adoption.
Unfortunately, I think the community is about as likely to change.
Re:Lisp's reputation is so bad that many people don't even t...
by SwellJoe on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @04:15PM
(#551551)
Unfortunately, I think the community is about as likely to change.
I agree. They've had longer than anyone to figure out the "community" thing, and they've self-selected into near obscurity.
Both, actually. But moreso the folks who complain about parentheses. I suspect that anyone who uses that as their reason for not learning or liking Lisp simply would never consider Lisp long enough to know anything more about the language. I just think it's more likely because they like "industry standard" languages, and have no obvious on-the-job use for Lisp, but they don't want to say "I am intellectually incurious about languages and different programming paradigms". I think those same people would never learn Lua or Haskell, despite a distinct lack of crazy parentheses.
Many people complain about parentheses
Many people complain about significant whitespace in Python and sigils in Perl. Either one has orders of magnitude more developers and more code being written in it on a daily basis. It is a triviality, and the kind of folks who pick out trivialities to complain about are not the kind of folks you can convert. They're not going to learn your favorite language, unless you make it look exactly like their favorite language. Since Lisp can't look like Java or C# or C or Visual Basic or PHP, without losing a lot of what makes Lisp Lisp, that's not a useful pursuit.
So, I'm simply saying that talking over parentheses over and over again is ignoring the real problems and focusing on the one that everyone knows won't change. It's a perfect flame war talking point, but it's not what's keeping people away from Lisp.