Re:Bubble or No, This Virtual Currency Is a Lot of Coin in A...
by eric_bullington on Monday April 08, 2013 @09:59AM
(#5511687)
Can you please show me the evidence you mention that shows that most Bitcoins are hoarded? I'm genuinely curious -- the main metric I'm aware of is Bitcoin Days Destroyed, and that metric seems to show that hoarding is actually steadily decreasing over time.
Re:Bubble or No, This Virtual Currency Is a Lot of Coin in A...
by SkyMarshal on Monday April 08, 2013 @02:16PM
(#5513478)
http://eprint.iacr.org/2012/584.pdf
~80% of BTC are dormant, eg being hoarded.
>and that metric seems to show that hoarding is actually steadily decreasing over time.
This is the big question, isn't it. It's completely understandable the early adapters are hoarding, expecting a med/long-term payoff on their investment via appreciation. But will that continue indefinitely, or change eventually?
And dumping even a portion of that into the system would have significant price effect, and given how so many people seem to value BTC by its price more than its unique utility, what effect will that have on the economy.
So the question is how are the marginal supply and demand determined? The marginal demand is subject to spikes in interest, media coverage, the Cyprus crisis (I really doubt the latter is meaningful but perhaps it makes people everywhere think they want to move out of bank deposits. People certainly attribute things to it). The marginal supply is based on (1) mining, which happens at a fixed rate and (2) people who wish to exit Bitcoin, which is subject to lots of whims.
Lots of evidence shows that most Bitcoins are hoarded, so it's possible that what we see is just a supply crunch - nobody wants to sell their Bitcoins and some people want to buy. I suppose the natural way to answer that is to go look at historical exchange volume across all the exchanges (or, as a first-cut proxy, just Mt. Gox).