News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by mklurfeld on Monday April 06, 2009 @07:47PM (#549921)
Sort of fitting that a man who taught at the University of Chicago and who has Larry Summers for an advisor would use economics for more than just balancing a national budget.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by jacoblyles on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:54PM (#550023)
>"Sort of fitting that a man who taught at the University of Chicago and who has Larry Summers for an advisor would use economics for more than just balancing a national budget."

I wish he would start with that.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by patrickg-zill on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:01PM (#549940)
Wow, the Hopeychange flavored Kool-Aid hasn't run out yet!
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by kirse on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:06PM (#549952)
I agree, people want change but they hardly know what they're in for, especially with universal healthcare "reform"... Some other recent notable changes...

- push to eliminate US nuclear weapons

- encouraging an international currency and removing the US dollar from a position of power

- spending $3.55 trillion for 2010 ($400bn over '09), when we've already committed $12.8 trillion to the recession

- increasing the marginal tax rate to the highest levels since Clinton

- letting North Korea get away with launching missiles over Japan

- taking over private businesses and forcing out their CEOs

I guess you always need a Carter to usher in a Reagan.

...And bring on the drive-by downmods with no responses.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by gabrielroth on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:32PM (#549993)
OK, here's a response:

> push to eliminate US nuclear weapons

I have seen no evidence of anyone in the administration suggesting any such thing.

> encouraging an international currency and removing the US dollar from a position of power

Ditto.

> spending $3.55 trillion for 2010 ($400bn over '09), when we've already committed $12.8 trillion to the recession

What's the problem with that? Be specific.

> increasing the marginal tax rate to the highest levels since Clinton

'to the highest levels since Clinton' means 'to a higher level than after Bush's tax cuts.' Was the economy, and the federal treasury, in better shape in 2000 (when Clinton left office) or eight years later?

> letting North Korea get away with launching missiles over Japan

Given that this happened two days ago, it's a little early to assess the administration's response.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by catz on Monday April 06, 2009 @09:59PM (#550098)
> > push to eliminate US nuclear weapons

> I have seen no evidence of anyone in the administration suggesting any such thing.

Really? What about: "Obama Calls for Nuclear Free World, Says U.S. Will Lead" (http://english.chosun.com/w21data/html/news/200904/200904060...)

Search Google news for US nuclear weapons.

> > spending $3.55 trillion for 2010 ($400bn over '09), when we've already committed $12.8 trillion to the recession

> What's the problem with that? Be specific.

Uhm... Spending huge amounts of money that the USA doesn't have isn't such a good idea?

> > increasing the marginal tax rate to the highest levels since Clinton

> 'to the highest levels since Clinton' means 'to a higher level than after Bush's tax cuts.' Was the economy, and the federal treasury, in better shape in 2000 (when Clinton left office) or eight years later?

When Clinton left office there was a recession (in 2000 and 2001). It was called the dot com bubble.

Oh. Also take into account that the Democrats controlled Congress the past few years. So maybe it is the Democrat's fault for the current mess?

> > letting North Korea get away with launching missiles over Japan

> Given that this happened two days ago, it's a little early to assess the administration's response.

Didn't Obama want to cut ballistic missile defence?

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by mattobrien on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @03:09AM (#550571)
There is a lot of parroting of talking points to unpack here. First, you assume that drawing down our nuclear program is a priori bad. This is clearly not so. Consider that the greatest threat of terrorists gaining access to nuclear weapons comes from so-called looses nukes in ex-Soviet states. If eliminating some of our weapons will induce them to do the same, this would seem to lessen the chance that apocalyptic weapons will fall into the hands of people who would use them. We could eliminate 9000 nukes and still have more than enough to kill all life on the planet several times over. If the Russians and other ex-Soviet states eliminate a commensurate number of weapons, I think that'd be a good trade.

As for $3.55 trillion for 2010 - unfortunately, I think it's probably necessary. Global manufacturing and trade are falling at rates faster than any seen during the Great Depression. Debt levels are higher now than back then. Deleveraging will take quite awhile. And while some have claimed Japan's deficit spending during its lost decade failed, since growth petered out at 1%, Richard Koo of Nomura makes a fairly convincing case that this was actually a success: they averted a full-scale depression, after all. (http://paul.kedrosky.com/archives/2009/04/richard_koo_on.htm...)

Saying that Obama has increased marginal tax rates to the highest level since Clinton is a cheap rhetorical trick. I don't think top rates going from 36% to 39.6% represents the tipping point between capitalism and socialism. And lower top marginal tax rates under Bush certainly didn't create a booming economy. This is the worst economy in 80 years. Also, remember that under Eisenhower, top rates were as high as 90%. However, those top rates only applied to individuals with incomes around $75 million in today's dollars. I think there's a convincing argument to be made for introducing more brackets at the top of the tax bracket - lumping in people making 300k with people raking in several million a year makes little sense. Nate Silver made this case a few weeks ago. (http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2009/03/missing-1000000-tax-b...)

Forgive me if I'm not scared about Obama firing CEOs of bailed out firms. Like it or not, certain companies are judged to be too economically, socially, and politically important to fail. If we're going to bail out these firms, getting rid of the incompetents who brought them onto the dole seems like the obvious first step. I wish Obama would get rid of Ken Lewis and the other banking geniuses who played such a large role in bringing on this collapse.

Letting North Korea "get away with firing a missile over Japan." This is disingenuous on so many levels. First, it was a dud, not a missile. Second, it's not as if George W. Bush or Clinton was able to deter North Korea either. Kim Jong Il is determined to starve his people to develop weapons. Short of going to war - which would devastate Seoul and kill millions - there are no good options aside from pressing the Chinese to press North Korea more forcefully.

And finally, you are aware that ballistic missile defense does not actually exist, and likely won't exist in the near future, right? It's something Reagan made up and threw untold billions of dollars into to scare the Soviets. What's the point of pouring money into a nonexistent technology - especially when we are going bankrupt? Ballistic missile defense might be a bigger scam than Bernie Madoff.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by anamax on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @09:17AM (#550828)
> Forgive me if I'm not scared about Obama firing CEOs of bailed out firms. ... If we're going to bail out these firms, getting rid of the incompetents who brought them onto the dole seems like the obvious first step.

Getting rid of incompetents sounds like a great idea. Too bad that Obama isn't interested.

We're still waiting for the politcal class to take a hit. (Barney Frank anyone?)

Heck - we're still waiting for Obama to fire advisors who ran Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into the ground.

> What's the point of pouring money into a nonexistent technology

It's unclear how being able to hit and destroy ballistic missles in certain cases is "nonexistent technology".

Nope - it's not deployed, but ....

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by anamax on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @09:10AM (#550821)
> Also, remember that under Eisenhower, top rates were as high as 90%.

Also remember the vast array of shelters and the like that went away with the Reagan tax rate cuts. If you're going to argue that someone isn't telling the whole story, it's poor form to leave out huge details.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by unalone on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:33PM (#549996)
Perhaps, kirse, we think that change won't take just 2 months. Maybe we still think that in these next 4 years, a lot of awesome stuff will happen, and that the changes we have seen are all pretty good.

Also perhaps we've studied history and realize that Reagan was a terrible president, lied through his teeth, and hurt the United States in a lot of ways, while Jimmy Carter went on to do a lot of good, and maybe we're offended by your little smirky statement.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by catz on Monday April 06, 2009 @10:02PM (#550102)
> and hurt the United States in a lot of ways

During the 8 years that Reagan was president the US economy grew by over 30%. This is an amazing feat.

> while Jimmy Carter went on to do a lot of good

Really? Do you think Carter was a good president?

I wonder who created the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_Reinvestment_Act#Rela...)

which had a pretty big hand in the sub-prime meltdown.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by unalone on Monday April 06, 2009 @10:08PM (#550108)
Yeah, Reagan did some good things. He also created the atmosphere in which presidents are judged more by clever quips than by experience and plans, he turned the US political scene into a scene of nonstop drama, and there was that Contra thingie that he outright lied about.

Carter wasn't good in office, but after leaving he did incredible things. And he always, always, took what he did seriously.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by MaysonL on Monday April 06, 2009 @11:20PM (#550223)
And, just like Obama, he felt that getting rid of all the nuclear weapons in the world would be a good thing.

See http://mediamatters.org/items/200812080009

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by gnaritas on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @02:11AM (#550499)
It would be a good thing. Whether or not it's achievable is entirely a different matter but if that genie could be put back in the bottle it'd be a wonderful thing.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by catz on Monday April 06, 2009 @10:57PM (#550169)
> more by clever quips than by

I dislike superficial things such as that. The whole smooth talking and celebrity thing is not for me. But in all fairness, the president that is the most like that is Barrack Obama.

One thing that was good about Bush was that he was not very charismatic. This allowed people to judge him by his actions (and no cult of celebrity existed around him).

The cult of personality that you build around a lot of politicians (esp. Obama) will be bad for you in the long run.

> and there was that Contra thingie that he outright lied about

Here is a quote from WP:

> While President Ronald Reagan was a supporter of the Contra cause,[4] there has not been any evidence uncovered showing that he authorized this plan.

I would not be surprised if he did not know what was happening. The CIA did a lot of things that would fall into a “morally grey area” during the cold war. A lot of these things needed to be done.

> Carter wasn't good in office, but after leaving he did incredible things.

Admittedly he did better than Al Gore, but what did he really accomplish? His habitat for Humanity project is for me stupid.

Why would you get foreign volunteers to build a house in a country with high unemployment? The economic effects was not thought through well – it would disadvantage labourers in the country.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by gnaritas on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @02:10AM (#550498)
Perhaps you missed the word volunteers. Habitat for Humanity has helped a lot of people; nit picking the source of the volunteers is uncalled for.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by Kyderdog on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @04:28PM (#551574)
I would be surprise if Regan knew what was happening from day one. BIH Ron.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by kragen on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @04:43AM (#550638)
The excellent Wikipedia section you linked to makes it crystal clear that the CRA, which passed in 1977, had no causal role in the subprime meltdown that started in 2007. That should be immediately obvious to the most casual observer, since there were 30 years between the events in question, but in case you were doubting, the article draws on a wide variety of sources of evidence.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by catz on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @08:24AM (#550766)
> The excellent Wikipedia section you linked to makes it crystal clear that the CRA, which passed in 1977, had no causal role in the subprime meltdown

Where?

Here are a few quotes:

> Economist Stan Liebowitz wrote in the New York Post that a strengthening of the CRA in the 1990s encouraged a loosening of lending standards throughout the banking industry. He also charges the Federal Reserve with ignoring the negative impact of the CRA.

> Jeffrey A. Miron, a senior lecturer in economics at Harvard University, in an opinion piece for CNN, calls for “getting rid” of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, as well as policies like the Community Reinvestment Act that “pressure banks into subprime lending.”[60]

> asked if the CRA provided the “fuel” for increasing subprime loans, former Fannie Mae CEO Franklin Raines said it might have been a catalyst encouraging bad behavior

> CRA, which passed in 1977, had no causal role in the subprime meltdown that started in 2007.

Uhm... You know that it was "strengthened" (Expanded) by Clinton twice?

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by themic86 on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:40PM (#550003)
You make it sound like man's progression towards interdependence doesn't warrant some degree of socialized changed in areas that are clearly underperforming in the reign of "private enterprise". No one said change was going to be easy... or cheap. We brought this upon ourselves when we realized farming and gathering was easier than hunting and gathering.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by MaysonL on Monday April 06, 2009 @11:28PM (#550241)
Actually farming is harder than hunting: it's just that people/acre is much higher for farmers than hunters, and farmers, being tied to the land, are more easily governed, supporting expansionist governments which drive the hunter-gatherers out. But I agree: that was the turning point.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by themic86 on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @12:39PM (#551204)
Yeah - the point isn't so much the ease of farming, rather it's necessity in order to increase the 'people / acre ' and the inherent interdependence of people as a result. we've been moving towards socialism since birth.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by DarkShikari on Monday April 06, 2009 @08:43PM (#550007)
The top marginal tax rate was far higher under Reagan than it is now. If Reagan was around today, he'd probably think it should be raised.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by viggity on Monday April 06, 2009 @10:29PM (#550138)
what? really? It was higher under Reagan, he did the best he could to lower it, but you can only do so much with both houses full of democrats. I'd love to know why you would think Reagan would want higher taxes, everything I've read would say otherwise.
Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by rjurney on Monday April 06, 2009 @11:22PM (#550228)
Reagan lowered taxes, realized he lowered them too far, then raised them to get revenues back up. Ended up at a much smaller cut than he initially got through. Can't find a best link, but google 'Deficit Reduction Act reagan' and you'll get lots of hits.

But that was a different, more responsible era than the last administration.

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by ellyagg on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @01:50AM (#550475)
Just to clarify, Reagan's tax cuts were actually a revenue windfall for the Treasury, as it unlocked a ton of capital gains that investors had been sitting on and resulted in an economic expansion that, aside from a brief recession in 90-91, pushed through the end of Clinton's administration[1].

[1] Not that Bush Sr. and Clinton deserve no credit, of course, Some folks have unfairly vilified Bush Sr., but the fact is, economists agree that the US was emerging from recession before the end of his administration

Re:How Obama used behavioral economics to win the election, ... by rjurney on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @11:59AM (#551118)
And yet, he raised taxes to get more revenue for the federal government because lowering them had reduced federal revenue too far.