News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by JennyZ on Thursday April 04, 2013 @06:55AM (#5491910)
You can get a free SSL certificate at https://www.startssl.com/ , so that should not be a reason to keep you from using it.

I do agree that the extreme mistrust of browsers towards self-signed certificates is an odd thing.

Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by derefr on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:23AM (#5492001)
> I do agree that the extreme mistrust of browsers towards self-signed certificates is an odd thing.

No, not at all; it's the whole point of SSL. The guy MITMing an SSLed website can create a cert for that site himself, but he can't get it signed by a CA. So he has to sign it himself. Thus, from the browser's perspective, all self-signed certs are possible instances of "there used to be a CA-signed cert here, but now you're being MITMed."

Now, that's not to say something like self-signed certs wouldn't be nice--given some sort of distributed pin cache, we could have something closer to an SSH/PGP model where everyone's current self-signed cert "fingerprint" is on file, and alarm bells go off if you see a cert different from the one you're supposed to see. But without that, self-signing is literally no more secure than no SSL at all: anyone else can also self-sign to MITM you.

Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by claudius on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:30AM (#5492021)
> but he can't get it signed by a CA.

I strongly doubt that.

Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by derefr on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:33AM (#5492033)
Well, like I said--it's the whole point of SSL. If he can (and the CA responsible isn't immediately shut down), it means SSL is fundamentally broken.
Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by lmm on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:00AM (#5492311)
It's free but they charge you to revoke a certificate, which is quite unfortunate as it discourages people from revoking if they e.g. leak their private key.
Re:How to implement HTTPS in an insufficient manner by dmm on Thursday April 04, 2013 @10:25AM (#5492826)
Browsers mistrust self-signed certificates because that's what a MITM attack would look like.