Re:Only external comments (on HN) allowed?
by bpatrianakos on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @09:10AM
(#5485770)
Sort of. I think HN is where you come to talk to other smart people about a topic. A blog's comment section is where you communicate directly with the author and a much broader, more random group of people. The latter is hit or miss with regards to quality but sometimes people surprise you.
But unless the blogger uses very specific software (read: excluding static generators), there is no way to know someone has just posted a comment to a post you wrote two years ago. I'd much rather them send me an email so I can answer in due time rather than let the comment rot, and look like an ass for not responding.
Honestly, I understand your argument and I respect it. But if it's a two-way communication, email is better albeit private; if it's between more than two people, then I feel like HN or alike is a better place.
Re:Only external comments (on HN) allowed?
by jaimebuelta on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:49AM
(#5492091)
Not sure if I understand the argument. Most of the blog comment systems (WP, Discuss, etc) will send an email when a new comment is posted. Even two years later...
My aversion for blog comments stems from how little we can trust content there: can I use "pg" as a username on your blog and impersonate Paul Graham? Where do the avatars come from? etc. Lots of little questions of whether or not I can trust what's being written in the comments.
Other than that, there is also the issue of quality: is there a system (e.g. karma, up/downvotes) that prunes the bad comments? the spam?
What about the ever-so-different way the comments are presented on blogs? Are comments threaded or linear?
To me, HN is the perfect framework for good conversations.