Re:Explicit vs. Clever
by tome on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @04:30PM
(#5481887)
One of the nice things about Python is that it has syntactic sugar for this. I find
very easy to understand in terms of natural language. Still, now I've learned Haskell I'd prefer to write
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Are we having a code example party? I like Clojure:
(map :total orders)Frankly, I would like to have more code example parties.
Too often, differences between programming languages are treated as strictly philosophical arguments. Comparing and contrasting actual code is far more interesting, in my opinion.
I'm partial to
select total from orders
myself. I really wish was as much progress on syntaxes for expressing relational algebra as there is for the functional stuff. Dealing with map and apply seems a bit fiddly and low-level for what should be a straightforward thing to express declaratively. (defmacro select [total _ coll]
(let [total (keyword total)]
`(map ~total ~coll)))
(select total from orders)
Problem solved!Nice.
Here are some interesting non-macro variants, first in Rebol:
select: func [block] [
totals: []
parse block [
set this word!
'from
set coll word!
(totals: map-each n (get coll) [get in n this])
]
totals
]
; then later...
select [total from orders]
;; nb. `select` is a core function provided by Rebol
;; so remember this example overwrites that
;; (in this scope/context) :)
;;
;; Alternative `dialect` to strive for would be..
;;
;; doMap [select total from orders]
And also in Io: select := method(
msg := call argAt(0)
this := msg name
coll := msg next next name
newMsg := message(COLL map) // COLL just a placeholder message
newMsg setName(coll) // Now been changed to correct var provided
newMsg next appendArg(this asMessage)
call sender doMessage(newMsg)
)
# then later...
select(total from orders)
Both examples work at runtime. However in Io you can also amend the AST directly.There's a GHC (Haskell) extension which lets you use list comprehensions which read like SQL: http://www.haskell.org/ghc/docs/7.2.1/html/users_guide/synta...
I agree, but I think that `map` is already a declarative interface (albeit to an implementation that is presumably functional).
Re:Explicit vs. Clever
by damncabbage on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @06:56PM
(#5482789)
Party time with Ruby:
orders.map(&:total)
... Where :total is a symbol, and & is asking :total for the Proc version of itself (a Proc being an anonymous function of sorts), and map is then calling that Proc with a single argument (an order from the list of orders).More detail: http://stackoverflow.com/a/1217114/3528
Yeah you're welcome to bring Clojure to my party. I've never met him/her before but he/she looks like other languages I get on well with.
These are also nice and would like to join in the party :)
map *.total, @orders; # perl6
@orders.map: *.total; # perl6 OO
map {$_->total} @orders; # perl5
orders map(total) # Io
map-each n orders [n/total] ; Rebol
Re:Explicit vs. Clever
by ricardobeat on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @05:30PM
(#5482239)
No need to go that far, CoffeeScript can do both:
totals = (order.total for order in orders)
totals = orders.map (o) -> o.total
Re:Explicit vs. Clever
by jimmaswell on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:27PM
(#5483568)
The c# syntax, myNewList = (from i in myList where i > 3 && i != 7 select i * 4).toList(), is nice too. Similar to using LINQ, myList.Where(i => i > 3), but I don't believe that form allows an easy use of the i * 4 part. One annoyance I have with .NET is there are too many types that are similar-but-not-quite a List<>, making me do conversions often. At least it's usually not much more than a .ToList(), except in the case of the controls in a Windows Form, which are their own weird list-type structure that doesn't support that.
Re:Explicit vs. Clever
by dbattaglia on Thursday April 04, 2013 @07:59AM
(#5492114)
For older .Net collections you can use Cast<T>() to get LINQ goodness. Something like this would work:
var values = from x in combobox.Items.Cast<ComboBoxItem>() where x.Value > 5 select x.Value;