News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear HN "Who's hiring" posters - Why my job search on HN ... by argonaut on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @06:16AM (#5478470)
> One replied, and was very thankful for the feedback and promised to work on it. He replied a few months later thanking me again. Two didn't reply, which means my hour was not only wasted, but I actually sent feedback that they didn't want or appreciate (which means they now think I'm an asshole).

I completely disagree. You're assuming that lack of reply = ungrateful and now they hate you, which is a completely ridiculous assumption. If someone rejects me and sends me feedback, I appreciate that but I'm not going to bother sending them an email thanking them - because there is really nothing more to discuss. What's next? Should I expect you to thank me for thanking you (does not thanking me for thanking you make me think you're an asshole?)

Re:Dear HN "Who's hiring" posters - Why my job search on HN ... by iaw on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:41AM (#5479963)
I think it's more a matter of the applicant recognizing that his criticisms were in a spirit of helping and responding with gratitude for the additional help. The difference between a two line rejection and a 3 paragraph well-thought critique is a good amount of time.

If it isn't clear to me why I didn't obtain a position I ask for clarification (and reconsideration), usually the response I get is fairly good.

As to pbiggar, I think he's shown a great deal more care and consideration to his applicants than most do, and I for one appreciate that (even if we've never corresponded).

Re:Dear HN "Who's hiring" posters - Why my job search on HN ... by pbiggar on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @11:10AM (#5479727)
Your use of the word "bother" is curious: a two line email is too much?

But to answer your question, rejections are often met with a short note saying "thanks for the time", wishing us well, and hoping we meet again in the future.

Re:Dear HN "Who's hiring" posters - Why my job search on HN ... by argonaut on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @07:29AM (#5485375)
Your question is irrelevant to my main point: that you're making a huge, unwarranted assumption that people who don't reply are necessarily ungrateful.

As someone who has rejected people in the past and has told people why they were rejected, I have never expected nor felt in any way entitled to receive a response. I have told them why I have decided not to hire them. Some people thank me for the critique. Others do not. It doesn't matter and I certainly don't make the huge logical leap of assuming that those who don't reply dislike me personally.

Re:Dear HN "Who's hiring" posters - Why my job search on HN ... by pbiggar on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @08:03PM (#5490108)
I think you misunderstand. I am not assuming they are bad people who have bad opinions of me (obviously, I can't tell). Rather, I am taking a conservative position about whether I have offended them: I suspect I have, and its better not to do that.