News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by rayiner on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @01:39AM (#5477861)
One of the best life lessons is that labor is a market just like any other, and prices are set based on supply and demand. Whether a CEO creates more value than 100 engineers under him is neither here nor there.[1]

[1] Which is a fact that cuts both ways. It means that CEOs aren't "overpaid" just because they aren't more productive relative to their salary, but it also means that it's non-sensical to use income as a proxy for anything else as is often done.

Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by richardw on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @03:34AM (#5478121)
The CEO-pay market isn't the same as a generic market though. The influence of the principal-agent problem is obvious, where 'management' is motivated to increase its own remuneration over time, and rarely drop it. (Yes, external directors are involved in remuneration but they're still not as motivated as the investors to keep costs in check.)

If only stock investors set the demand for management against the available supply and management was not involved (and at times, the price was allowed to drop significantly), it'd be more like a normal market.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem

Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by krichman on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @02:17AM (#5477939)
Yes, exactly. That's why claiming the salary has anything to do with productivity is absurd. It's a combined measurement of how badly the company wants your skillset and how well you can negotiate.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by legutierr on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @02:27AM (#5477966)
Well, sometimes it's because your friends are on the board of directors, and they are doing you a favor (with someone else's money) in the hopes that you will return the favor to them when the time comes.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by patrickk on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @08:19AM (#5478829)
Or sometimes the CEO stacks the board with his buddies, so he almost certainly won't be fired and any votes on pay increases will sail through.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by mtrimpe on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @07:09AM (#5478601)
And don't forget including your culture's belief of how steep the power law curve of rewards is supposed to be.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by jeremyjh on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:56AM (#5479257)
CEOs of public companies are in the business of extracting wealth from that company. The ruling caste of equity lords all work towards this goal together by creating closed network systems of board members and executives; an executive Dave in Company A will get paid by board member Steve while Dave in turn sits on the board for Company B and assures payment for Steve who is an executive there. The selection process for an executive position is based on who is next in line in the network. I don't see any market forces at work here.
Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by Silhouette on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @09:21AM (#5479073)
One of the best life lessons is that labor is a market just like any other, and prices are set based on supply and demand.

Unfortunately, the labour market is a particularly illiquid and inefficient one, where things like actual value generated or risks taken tend to correlate poorly with compensation.

That is, prices in the labour market are set based on supply, demand, and huge distortions mostly caused by inability to judge value accurately and/or conflicts of interest.

Re:Powerful Thoughts From Paul Graham by imgabe on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @10:23AM (#5479402)
Considering the web of contacts and interrelationships between CEOs of companies and board members responsible for hiring and determining the pay of those CEOs, I highly, highly doubt that the market for CEO labor is anything approaching a free, efficient market that would arrive at an ideal price.