How is that at all strange? Hypocritical, certainly, but not strange. People want the government to take money from others and give it to them but not the other way around. That is basically the entire basis of politics on the question of government spending.
I think part of it is that farmers were historically socially conservative, but not particularly free-market oriented. Given the miscellaneous catastrophic risks to livelihood that small farmers face from fluctuations in weather and prices, from the perspective of economic politics, farmers have typically been in favor of vaguely socialized systems that share some of the risks and stabilize prices. Even when it wasn't done via the state, the tendency was towards agricultural cooperatives and other kinds of economic pooling schemes.