News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by dejb on Sunday April 05, 2009 @10:33AM (#547404)
Newspaper journalist complains about Internet. Who would have thought?
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by tomsaffell on Sunday April 05, 2009 @12:39PM (#547489)
Guardian journalist complains about someone making money. Who would have thought?

FYI for non UK readers: "Editorial articles in The Guardian are generally in sympathy with the middle-ground liberal to left-wing end of the political spectrum" (http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/The+Guardian). UK print media has ~10 national newspapers, which are politically segmented (and income segmented). Hence editorial articles benefit from being fairly political, since they address a readership that is both homogeneous in its political views, and different to the national average in its political views. Tribalism..

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by swolchok on Sunday April 05, 2009 @01:34PM (#547527)
This and its parent are ad hominem attacks (DH1 -- see http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html) -- it may be in the writer's interest to complain about the Internet, but that does not mean that the writer's points are incorrect.
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by russell on Sunday April 05, 2009 @03:38PM (#547655)
"..ad hominem attacks", are you kidding? They are questioning the writer's objectivity, as do it. The writer's points/ conclusions are incorrect. The solution is not to constrain or eliminate Google, it's for the Guardian and the other content providers to adapt to be relevant.
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by kragen on Sunday April 05, 2009 @03:41PM (#547658)
Questioning the writer's objectivity rather than rebutting their points is an ad hominem attack. I'm not kidding. If you think the writer's points and conclusions are incorrect (I do) you should write a rebuttal, rather than pointing out that the writer isn't disinterested. Interested parties can still make valid arguments!
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by benmathes on Sunday April 05, 2009 @04:32PM (#547715)
The ad-hominem fallacy fallacy: http://plover.net/~bonds/adhominem.html

A critique is not ad-hominem if the target is a character trait relevant to the speaker's point.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by _pius on Sunday April 05, 2009 @09:07PM (#548028)
Sure, people sometimes misuse the term ad hominem, but not in this case. The comment said that:

"Editorial articles in The Guardian are generally in sympathy with the middle-ground liberal to left-wing end of the political spectrum"

I fail to see how being liberal implies the bizarre views in the article. Bringing up the political leaning of the Guardian was a bit of a cheap shot and not at all germane to the topic.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by kragen on Tuesday April 07, 2009 @04:12AM (#550615)
"A critique is not ad-hominem if the target is a character trait relevant to the speaker's point."

As I interpret your sentence, that is not what the article you are quoting says, and it is also not correct. This is irrelevant here, however, because the character trait being discussed is not related to the speaker's point; it is merely an argumentum ad hominem.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by mstoehr on Sunday April 05, 2009 @06:35PM (#547849)
How do you think that the character traits of the writer are relevant to his case against Google?
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by benmathes on Sunday April 05, 2009 @09:41PM (#548070)
Claiming that the author was not objective is relevant to his argument.
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by gjm11 on Sunday April 05, 2009 @04:54PM (#547737)
Why on earth are you linking to encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com instead of wikipedia.com? By doing so you give people following your link staler content, a bunch of ads, worse formatting, and no ability to fix errors they find.

(For those who don't know: e.t.c is one of many sites that just scrape the entirety of Wikipedia -- er, I think they omit some bits, mostly in the hope of making the true origin of the material less obvious -- and re-present its content as if it's theirs, adding a bunch of paid advertisements, with just a bit of teeny-tiny small print crediting Wikipedia. This doesn't seem to me like behaviour we should be encouraging.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by tomsaffell on Sunday April 05, 2009 @07:16PM (#547890)
Valid question and valid points. To answer it: I linked to that because it's what I use, and I use that service because for me the benefit of aggregating many references into one outweighs the downsides (which you highlight). I'm not promoting it, so I would like to think that my linking to it can fall into the category of 'diversity of opinion is beneficial to the community'.
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by febeling on Sunday April 05, 2009 @12:34PM (#547482)
I was happy to see that other commenters where very little impressed with this article either, with the one above probably most to the point.

People don't see yet how instable these monopolies really are in the age of the internet. Once Google would really corrupt it's core product, search, someone could just go, download the clones of Googles software over at the apache foundation and upload it into a little EC2 cloud at Amazon. There is not even this network effect which allows Ebay to run successfully despite looking quite dated nowadays, because people feel they have to stick with them because eveybody else does.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by swolchok on Sunday April 05, 2009 @02:42PM (#547590)
Do you really think that the OSS world is on par with Google's army of (paid, full-time) engineers, and that EC2 is as efficient as (or, conceivably, even in the same ballpark as) Google's datacenter infrastructure? (Amazon's private infrastructure might be run as well, although they have very different concerns -- compare GFS (http://labs.google.com/papers/gfs.html) with Dynamo (http://s3.amazonaws.com/AllThingsDistributed/sosp/amazon-dyn...), for example.)
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by anamax on Sunday April 05, 2009 @09:19PM (#548040)
> that EC2 is as efficient as (or, conceivably, even in the same ballpark as) Google's datacenter infrastructure

Google's users don't care how efficiently it runs its datacenters.

Re:Google is just an amoral menace by swolchok on Sunday April 05, 2009 @11:00PM (#548207)
I don't know about that, mightn't inefficient datacenters cost more per query, leading to worse servers, leading to higher latency, which users care about?
Re:Google is just an amoral menace by anamax on Monday April 06, 2009 @01:43AM (#548403)
Yes, users care about latency, but less efficiency doesn't necessarily lead to higher latency. (I have no idea what "worse servers" means.)

As long as Google can afford to provide decent anwers with acceptable latency, it will have users.

I think that efficiency is like programming effort, algorithms, and programming languages in that users don't care. They only care about results and the costs that affect them.