News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No to "No UI" by ThomPete on Monday April 01, 2013 @10:27AM (#5473183)
The point about no UI isn't that you wont have a display, in fact you will have many many types of displays.

The point is that the actual interaction becomes invisible. I.e. not as much manual input but rather the input is based your everyday actions.

You take the train as you usually do. The system knows you normally get to work at 9 but it also know the train is delayed so you get a message that its delayed.

Thats the vision of the future, thats the seamless and non-obtrusive part.

Not that it wont be visually displayed.

The nest takes away much of the manual work you had to do (adjust based on when you are home etc) it doesn't remove the feedback mechanism.

Re:No to "No UI" by salgernon on Monday April 01, 2013 @12:15PM (#5473969)
About a dozen years ago I worked with a developer who built "smart house" applications. He was describing his home and how the house knew when he walked into a room and activated the lights. When he got into to bed, the lights in the room automatically went off. I asked him: "so, what do you do if you want to read in bed?" His reply was a quizzical look, and "?? The bed is for sleeping." He didn't understand how broken this mentality was.

The point is, if systems that anticipate your needs do not have adequate interface for working around them - and by adequate, I mean easily discoverable and intuitive, then they will be rejected by the majority of consumers. And with good reason. Technology should serve us, not require us to adapt to them.

Re:No to "No UI" by ThomPete on Monday April 01, 2013 @12:35PM (#5474121)
Well that depends on how meta you are prepared to take it :)

The UI is in itself forcing you to adapt to it by asking you to input data into it.

Your refrigerator does not require you to turn on the light when you open it. Instead it turns on when you open the door.

I see this not as a revolution but as a slow (but exponentially faster) evolution. As issues gets ironed out you can remove more and more manual labour from the system.

Re:No to "No UI" by andreasvc on Monday April 01, 2013 @04:54PM (#5475866)
You fail to address the point of how much control people are comfortable with giving away. Some lights are fine if they're fully automated (fridge). But for others people want to have some control (e.g., reading the bedroom, looking to see if there's a mosquito etc). So no, there appears to be a limit of how much UI you can take away.
Re:No to "No UI" by ThomPete on Monday April 01, 2013 @05:29PM (#5476043)
To be honest I dont understand what you disagree with in what I wrote.

My point is that how comfortable people are will change over time or depending on their situation.

I might use an ipad for reading instead and thus for me and million of other people that problem is not really there and you have a market.

The only way I can understand your comment is if you don't believe systems can become better over time.

I do.

Re:No to "No UI" by andreasvc on Monday April 01, 2013 @05:41PM (#5476132)
I didn't disagree with your comment but pointed out that it doesn't address this "no UI" concept and whether people actually want that. While it is likely that in the future more things will be automated, it's not going to converge to people not controlling anything. I do believe systems will become better over time, just not necessarily through not having any interface.
Re:No to "No UI" by ThomPete on Monday April 01, 2013 @05:56PM (#5476216)
And I didn't disagree that we dont need interfaces, more that the action (opening the fridge door) becomes the event trigger in itself.
Re:No to "No UI" by SkyMarshal on Monday April 01, 2013 @08:18PM (#5476878)
Good example of a misidentified problem. That engineer identified the problem as the lights need to be on when somebody is in a room and off otherwise, and off when the person lies down.

But the real problem is that turning the lights on and off normally takes too much effort (for a #firstworldproblem at least). You have to walk over and flip a switch, interrupting whatever you doing.

A better solution would be design a system that lets people control the lights with minimal effort - a gesture, or a clap, or a voice command. So you can turn on the lights only when dark and not during the day, or when you want to read in bed, etc.

Re:No to "No UI" by ollysb on Monday April 01, 2013 @10:41AM (#5473284)
I think "inferred preferences" sums it up pretty well. Automatically adjusted clocks were probably one of the first examples of this, get off a plane in a different country and your phone/watch is automatically adjusted to the current time zone.
Re:No to "No UI" by shurcooL on Monday April 01, 2013 @10:51AM (#5473367)
The main problem with that which needs to be addressed is when you don't know whether it has already switched to the new time zone, or if it's still about to switch. As a result, you don't know the time.
Re:No to "No UI" by ThomPete on Monday April 01, 2013 @11:09AM (#5473491)
Exactly! Excellent example.