News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rayiner on Sunday March 31, 2013 @09:32AM (#5468592)
Interesting article. My wife grew up in rural Iowa and told me the same story. Nobody even applied to the elite east and west coast schools. If you were a great student you applied to the university of Iowa.

She also thinks that elite colleges undervalue the kind of extracirriculars common in rural areas: FFA, 4H, etc. When I was in HS, our extracirriculars were things like robotics club sponsored by the DOD. In a way, both are representative of their region (middle America versus inside the beltway).

I think ultimately its bad for diversity to take ECs into account. Too much cultural and social bias inherent in that. Think about the kind of ECs elite colleges like to see: concert pianist, interning at a research lab, community service, etc. Unless you have a real sob story, "work" is not very high on that list. But by and large people who can spend all summer on community service projects are not people who have to work as teenagers to help support themselves.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by vwoolf on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:04AM (#5468640)
If you were a great student you applied to the university of Iowa.

Which is a very good school. The other problem a small but important segment of our society has is believing in the magic of very well marketed schools. Really, there are lots of good universities, and I don't think many people's lives are going to be made or broken by whether they're at U of Iowa or some other school, especially for undergrad.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rayiner on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:25AM (#5468687)
University of Iowa is a very good school, no doubt. But depending on what you want to do with your life, it can close a lot of doors. Top-tier banks and management consulting companies don't recruit heavily from U of I, nor do top-tier tech companies for that matter (though the distinction is less marked). When you look at the fraction of the upper echelons of corporate America that come from those backgrounds, that's significant. I went to a state school for undergrad, but where I currently work most people have at least one Ivy on their resume. The difference in our undergraduate social networks is really quite dramatic in terms of peoples' career trajectories.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by geogra4 on Sunday March 31, 2013 @06:26PM (#5470415)
What's a 'top tier tech company'? When I went to school at Penn State, we had Amazon, MS, Google, Cisco, Intel, Oracle, etc. all come to our career fair. It's not like quality graduates had trouble finding excellent jobs.

I had a roommate who ended up at JPMorgan, and a few more distant associates really hit the jackpot in the Oil and Gas industry.

I will agree that if your life goal is a 100/hr a week investment banking position or some top tier management consulting position in NYC then a big state school probably isn't where you want to be. But you can't study petroleum engineering at Yale so it works both ways.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rayiner on Sunday March 31, 2013 @07:04PM (#5470541)
Coming to a career fair is quite a bit different than coming to a school expecting to hire tons of people from there. Lots of companies go to career fairs at certain schools looking to pick off the very tippy-top kids, but they go to Stanford, Harvard, etc, looking to really fill their class. JPM doesn't care if it doesn't pick up anyone at UNC in a given year. It'd be a disaster to the recruiting people if they didn't pick up anyone at Wharton in a given year.

Of course you're right, these companies aren't the beginning and end of the great jobs available to college grads. If you have zero interest in these jobs, going to the most elite schools is much less important. At the same time, there is a reason a quarter of MIT grads end up in finance and consulting (pre-recession, it was a third). For better or worse, they offer relatively low-risk paths into the upper echelons of corporate America.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ritchiea on Monday April 01, 2013 @12:34AM (#5471456)
Penn State is not a typical public university. You might as well have said UC-Berkeley.

Hell Penn is a public university and an Ivy.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by sqrt on Monday April 01, 2013 @02:15AM (#5471752)
Penn and Penn State are distinct universities; Penn State is a public university (and not an Ivy), while Penn is a private university (and an Ivy).
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ritchiea on Monday April 01, 2013 @11:01AM (#5473438)
I knew that Penn & Penn State are distinct schools. Though I did not know that University of Pennsylvania is a private university. My mistake.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by stephencanon on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:38AM (#5468727)
On the other hand, a student who does well at U of I can absolutely get into the elite schools for grad school, at which point they become part of the club. It’s one more step, but the doors aren’t closed.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by geogra4 on Sunday March 31, 2013 @06:36PM (#5470453)
I would also argue that state school graduates have a different concept of what they want out of life. In general my social circle had more people who were comfortable in more traditional career paths such as accounting, actuarial, engineering, finance, teaching, etc.

Balancing a comfortable income and having a life were more important than striking it rich at all costs.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by Evbn on Sunday March 31, 2013 @10:41AM (#5468738)
The problem has has nothing to do with Iowa's status and everything to do with the banks+consultants hijacking of wealth in America.

You don't need to fix the schools, you need to fix the wealth structure.

There is no value in replacing a pack of NY assholes by a pack of IA assholes.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ritchiea on Monday April 01, 2013 @12:39AM (#5471473)
There are dozens of great schools that aren't Ivies. I used to be in your camp on this issue but one thing I noticed is that going to an Ivy gives you access to resources that you don't necessarily get at a great school that isn't an Ivy.

You can, without a doubt, get a great education outside of an elite school. But going to an Ivy gives you access to better speakers, better alumni networks, more institutional resources granted to students to do interesting/valuable things while they are at the university, the list goes on.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by ritchiea on Monday April 01, 2013 @11:02AM (#5473448)
Seriously a downvote? What is downvote worthy about this comment?

Is is really that controversial or incorrect to say you can get a great education in many places that don't have the same total resources as Ivies provide to their students?

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by bane on Sunday March 31, 2013 @12:51PM (#5469213)
She also thinks that elite colleges undervalue the kind of extracirriculars common in rural areas: FFA, 4H, etc.

An excellent point. The kinds of extracurriculars I had available to me growing up rural and poor were either things like Boy Scouts, 4H, or things of my own interest: community chamber orchestra or rock bands, demoscene, semi-local computer user groups, etc. I lived far enough from school that my bus ride ran a bit over an hour, once I got a car I stayed for a few after school clubs (poetry, chess) etc. but I usually didn't get home till it was too late for homework so I simply had to drop those few school sponsored activities.

While the tech magnet school an hour from my area had their very own Cray Supercomputer and sponsored robotics competitions, and all sort of other high-interest to college activities.

I can't really recall anybody from my school trying to get into the Iveys. The "big time" schools were all state schools either in my state, or the next state over for those really ambitious.

Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by rayiner on Sunday March 31, 2013 @01:00PM (#5469254)
The other big activity is things people do through their churches. But that plays poorly in college admissions too.
Re:The Ivy League Was Another Planet by 205guy on Tuesday April 02, 2013 @06:23PM (#5482586)
Funny that you mention Iowa, because I was just going to comment about that. I really think the OP and many commenters (including the parent) bring up a critical point: there are smart people and geniuses everywhere, and perhaps some of them are having doors closed to them, when it would be in everybody's interest to keep them open.

A while ago, HN had a long-form article-fest, and one that people linked to was an Esquire piece from 1983[1] about Robert Noyce. He came from Iowa and was a key in founding Intel--and from the way the article makes it sound, in putting men on the moon, as well (it's all connected anyway). What struck me is that several famous physicists were connected to Grinnell College in Iowa.

I suppose I'm a bit guilty of prejudice against the "fly-over states" at times, so that article and this thread were a good reminder (sort of a 1-2 punch) to knock me out of that thinking.

Perhaps part of that is also to see that such potential geniuses do not need to go away to the big city to reach their full potential, either. It would also be great if they could mature locally and contribute to the fields that are important to the communities they come from (agriculture, forestry, etc.).

[1] http://www.stanford.edu/class/e140/e140a/content/noyce.html