News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Lean Startup: A contrarian view by jacques_chester on Sunday March 31, 2013 @05:10AM (#5468168)
Some context here:

http://khitchdee.forumatic.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=297

(The site is a forum being used as a blog / CMS.)

I have my own reservations about the Lean Startup book -- but most of it comes down to an allergy to it that I developed from reading HN. I got around to it last week on a personal recommendation and it wasn't half bad.

I'd say the biggest problem with how people approach it is that they fixate on the MVP rather than the cycle. The MVP is just a particular cycle.

As benjaminsull pointed out, the Lean Startup disclaims coverage of domains with well understood product models and mature feature-development ecosystems.

Re:The Lean Startup: A contrarian view by adrianhoward on Sunday March 31, 2013 @05:49AM (#5468225)
I'd say the biggest problem with how people approach it is that they fixate on the MVP rather than the cycle. The MVP is just a particular cycle.

It's even worse than that. The problem I see is folks who focus on particular forms of the MVP. Not every damn product starts best with a launch page of some Google Adwords.

Lean Startup is neat. I'm finding a bunch of ideas from it stupidly useful. But it's going throught the Hype Cycle (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hype_cycle) amazingly quickly.

Re:The Lean Startup: A contrarian view by jacques_chester on Sunday March 31, 2013 @06:06AM (#5468251)
Yeah, it's not half bad. Like I said, I tend to instinctively avoid whatever book is being waved like a bible in HN circles.

So as I say, it was a surprise to see how different the expressed vision of MVP seems to be from what I got from the book. I got the impression that it was the first thing you could actually give to a user and have them use. Even if it was buggy and had a single feature.

The launch-page "MVP" isn't actually a product. It's market research.

Re:The Lean Startup: A contrarian view by adrianhoward on Sunday March 31, 2013 @06:19AM (#5468276)
I know this is somewhat heretical - but I don't actually like The Lean Startup book that much.

I was pointed to Lean Startup back in 2010 as a solution to some of the problems I was looking at. The folk I talked to, places like the LSC mailing list, and reading the online/offline writings of Steve Blank, Eric Ries and many others helped a lot.

I was really looking forward to Eric's book - but it didn't really hit the spot I was hoping it would hit. It's very much aimed (I think) at explaining the ideas to the world in general - rather than being a guide to folk who want to apply the ideas. There's nothing wrong with the former, but I was hoping for the latter.

Re:The Lean Startup: A contrarian view by jacques_chester on Sunday March 31, 2013 @07:10AM (#5468359)
Well if I had a complaint about Eric's book it's that there's a ton of undergraduate-essay padding at the front end. It could have been about 2/3rds as long and said all the same stuff.