However, when you learn to stop worrying and let the runtime decide it's so much nicer. It turns out that people have already optimised the framework, so at worst it's just as fast as the code I wrote. At best it's faster because the framework knows more about what it's capable of.
The biggest thing to realise is that while you can easily make things perform well in isolation the runtime can look at the bigger picture. There's no point making an operation run in 300ms if it blocks all other tasks on the server, when it could run in 600ms and allow everything else to keep going.
This smells like the classic leaky abstraction though. Like when people tried to paper over the difference between remote calls and local calls with abstract interfaces (CORBA, RMI, etc.). Everyone would say it was so awesome, remote calls look the same as local calls! But it wasn't awesome, it was horrible, because the details of the abstraction 'leaked' through and you got all kinds of problems from having delegated away what was actually one of the most critical, sensitive parts of your code to a layer you had no control over. 15 years later we're back to nearly everybody using REST because it turns out to be way better not to shove those abstractions on top of your most important code.
Now, I'm not saying that analogy is perfect here ... but it does remind me of it. Why should you care about the order of things? Just to suggest something, sometimes it's just useful to be able to reason about it. "We know the first operation definitely happened before the others, so an earlier one failing can't be a side effect of something a later one did ... oops, we don't know that any more. We actually have no idea what order they happened in."
In my experience, promises do fill this role if they're used in a suitable scenario.
There's nothing incongruous about that. It is the case that side effects should only happen on POST, PUT, and DELETE methods (and the like), but almost all webservers are written because of a need to use these.
If your webserver is all GETs and HEADs, then it is either trivial and you would have used someone else's instead of writing your own, or its sole purpose is to repackage and serve existing data from other sources - a rare use case among all webservers.
If you were to take an inventory of all the webservers out there, you would doubtless find that almost all of them exist in large part in order to create side effects.
A cache gets refreshed or added to. A user's viewcount is incremented. A new statistic is calculated and then stored. An item is marked as viewed. And these are all just on a GET.
On complex sites with a logged-in user, side effects are pretty much the norm.
Using a Promises, as opposed to reducing a list of computations async-style, also limits you to the Promise object's interface, so you lose (or at least add cruft to) the flexibility and composability of using native lists. By sequencing computations with lists, if I want some insight into what's happening, I just List.map(apply compose, logFunc). With promises, I have some work to do.
Promises have their uses, but it's definitely a tradeoff, and for most HTTP servers, I'd argue that their utility does seem a bit limited. I'd similarly say that making a point of using FRP to build a server would probably be a bit overkill for the task.
Because, in the end, what, semantically, is the difference between:
runqueue([func1,func2,func3,func4]); and func1().then(func2).then(func3).then(func4);
No significant difference at all, really. except the promises permit you much more flexibility and options.
The idea that webservers are "all about side effects" gives me a chill. The whole architecture concept of HTTP is no side effects, so to claim that it's all about side effects seems odd. It should only be the case for POST PUT or DELETE methods, and only in very specific ways.