Sure it would - all BigCo. has to do is point out that no human being rejected the applicants. For example, to reject older applicants just reject people based on salary expectations: younger workers will come in under the bar. BigCo. has a perfectly "legitimate" reason for all the older workers never getting an interview.
Just be creative with the criteria and filter based on the indirect criteria.
I don't think that argument would stand up in court. If the software you contracted to use explicitly applied screening criteria based on protected classes such as race or sex, then you would be found to be discriminating illegally.