News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Are Not Your Brain by jimbokun on Saturday April 04, 2009 @04:58PM (#546648)
"Of course consciousness is an emergent process that rises out of mind, body, and environment,"

This, I think, is his point.

"but if it doesn't take place within the brain, then where is it?"

My guess is he might say asking "where" consciousness takes place is a meaningless question.

Re:You Are Not Your Brain by branden on Saturday April 04, 2009 @05:21PM (#546672)
I take his point, but I think you can agree with it and still treat consciousness as something that takes place within the brain. I guess the disagreement is over whether body, brain, and environment are all literally parts of consciousness, or whether environment interpreted through the body is an input to a consciousness process that takes place within the brain. Noë doesn't make much of a case for his position, he only says it's a more comforting way to go about things. Well that's fine, but that doesn't say much about whether it's true.