Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by shadowrunner on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:37PM
(#5466248)
Am I to believe you? Even if these experiments do have importance, are they more important than being humane and ethical?
We're so damn advanced as a race, yet we can't come up with more humane alternatives?
We have record unemployment and pharmaceutical companies that are making billions in profits, why can't we experiment on humans who give consent and are fairly compensated? It's more humane to animals and people.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by unimpressive on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:40PM
(#5466260)
Because these experiments kill stuff.
The humans are more valuable, and I'm sorry that you'd rather see them die than a few rodents.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by shadowrunner on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:51PM
(#5466288)
And I'm sorry you lack insight and empathy towards both animals and people who could use the income to have a better life.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by GHFigs on Saturday March 30, 2013 @03:59PM
(#5466471)
The problem is you (as a scientist) don't know that an experimental subject will have a better life, or a life at all, and you don't have enough data about the risks to fairly compensate a person for taking those risks on. You're just making the cost of collecting data much more expensive while shifting the risk (of suffering, disability, death) from animals bred for the purpose to poor people.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by anoncow on Saturday March 30, 2013 @04:22PM
(#5466552)
While the topic was about animal suffering, you are talking about suffering in human subjects. As far as I know(and that is not much), human studies are done after animal studies. This means the drug is most likely not toxic to animals and by extension humans.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by GHFigs on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:59PM
(#5467233)
You didn't read the thread. He's suggesting doing human studies instead of animal studies.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by anoncow on Sunday March 31, 2013 @04:34AM
(#5468104)
Without animal studies, you are exposing human subjects to potentialy toxic drugs.
Re:Scientists Inject Human Brain Cells Into Mice, Make Them ...
by unimpressive on Sunday March 31, 2013 @05:10AM
(#5468166)
That's what we said.
These experiments are incredibly important for science and healthcare.