I think the GP is calling them "idiots" not because they use C in a dumb way, but because they keep using a language that is error-prone.
Re:Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
by hp50g on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:30PM
(#5466236)
You are wrong: I'm calling them idiots because they use C in a dumb way and don't stick it through valgrind etc.
Re:Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
by mikeash on Saturday March 30, 2013 @09:40AM
(#5465363)
"You can't really have a totally safe systems programming language (correct me if I'm wrong here)."
He doesn't seem to think that others would be better.
Re:Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
by jdboyd on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:42PM
(#5467072)
A type system that isn't 100% safe can still be a massive improvement over C or even C++.
Re:Of Lisp Macros and Washing Machines (2011)
by mikeash on Saturday March 30, 2013 @10:13PM
(#5467417)
Sure, but from the overall tone of the comment, it seems clear that he's blaming the "idiots", not the "C", because his only statement about alternatives to C is that they'll have similar problems.
This is a million times wrong. It's not about humans being smart or stupid, it's about humans being bad at being careful millions and millions of times without error.
The answer isn't to tell them to be more careful. They can be more careful, but they are human, so they will still make mistakes. The answer is for them to use higher level languages that eliminate whole classes of errors.