News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:D.C. (School) Vouchers: Better Results at a Quarter the Cost by karl11 on Saturday April 04, 2009 @02:23PM (#546508)
I think better teachers is more likely than selection bias. Teachers who are rewarded on merit will always outperform those rewarded for their seniority.
Re:D.C. (School) Vouchers: Better Results at a Quarter the Cost by misuba on Saturday April 04, 2009 @06:31PM (#546736)
How do you measure merit?
Re:D.C. (School) Vouchers: Better Results at a Quarter the Cost by grandalf on Saturday April 04, 2009 @07:02PM (#546766)
By seniority, of course! Or that is what the teachers' unions would have us believe.

Is measuring merit all that hard? It's done successfully higher ed. The bottom line is that we shouldn't worry so much about the concept of merit b/c we don't need a one-size-fits-all system. For example, some people prefer to go to a large public university where profs are "meritorious" if they publish and are at the cutting edge of research -- while others prefer to go to smaller schools with more of a focus on teaching and small class sizes.

Chances are with widespread voucher availability, K-12 education would become less cookie-cutter and would better address the diverse definitions of merit that exist.

Of course, states/cities could require certain curriculum, teacher SAT scores, etc., but such things would represent a floor rather than a ceiling on what "merit" is.

Re:D.C. (School) Vouchers: Better Results at a Quarter the Cost by tokenadult on Sunday April 05, 2009 @12:03AM (#547032)
How do you measure merit?

I would let the learners have power to shop, and we will know soon enough which teachers are doing a good job.