I agree there are some times when it's easy to accept only 10% or so: when there is a lot of obvious crap submitted. I'm currently organizing a conference with about a 30% acceptance rate, and it's somewhat painful, though. It's not one of the main catch-all conferences like OSDI, CHI, AAAI, SIGGRAPH, etc. which everyone submits to. Instead mostly people in the area submit to it, and a large proportion of the submissions are legitimately good. I would say 50% solid submissions from regular members of the community, 25% not-great submissions from people legitimately in the area, and 25% either crap or clearly off-topic.
So it'd be easy to choose which 50% to accept, but when you're accepting 30%, now some good work is being rejected, just because you have to hit the arbitrary acceptance-rate target to count as "selective" in certain U.S. universities' bibliometric systems. If we went down to a 20% acceptance rate (as some people are pushing, not b/c of quality but solely b/c it makes the conference look better bibliometrically), we'd have to fairly arbitrarily reject some more good papers.
We half-joke that the way to fix it next year is to spam the CfP to clearly unsuitable places, in order to elicit a flood of crap submissions that we can then easily reject, allowing us to hit a 30% (or 20%, or lower) acceptance rate without having to reject any good papers.
> Instead mostly people in the area submit to it, and a large proportion of the submissions are legitimately good.
Working groups or invite only workshops might work better in this regard. It depends on your area though.
> So it'd be easy to choose which 50% to accept, but when you're accepting 30%, now some good work is being rejected, just because you have to hit the arbitrary acceptance-rate target to count as "selective" in certain U.S. universities' bibliometric systems.
Its more about how tenure cases work in universities. Your judges don't read your papers, they just look at your bib.
> If we went down to a 20% acceptance rate, we'd have to fairly arbitrarily reject some more good papers.
In my reviewing experience, the PC never had to reject papers based on too many good papers; if anything we had to accept papers of questionable quality to fill the conference up. The rejection notices that PC chairs send out about there being too many good papers are often lies. But maybe our fields have different problems :) I'm a firm believer in accepting all the good papers and rejecting all the bad ones.
> We half-joke that the way to fix it next year is to spam the CfP to clearly unsuitable places, in order to elicit a flood of crap submissions that we can then easily reject, allowing us to hit a 30% (or 20%, or lower) acceptance rate without having to reject any good papers.
Just use Weibo to advertise your conference. There is a lot of talent in China and India who want to make it big, not all of it is great yet, but it will definitely push down your accept rates.
I'm a big fan of low acceptance rates in conferences. There are way too many mediocre papers that get into conferences I care about even when the acceptance rate is low. Also, the surge in papers submitted from China has pushed everyone's acceptance rates down, and quality isn't necessarily getting better. Disclaimer: I'm submitting from china these days.
In computer science, if you look at low accept conferences like OSDI/SOSP (systems), you'll see some safe (uncontroversial) papers getting accepted but most of them are just good and interesting. Now, compare that to CHI where the accept rate is still competitive but the quantity is huge. The quality there seems much less consistent.
When I review for conferences these days, I'll get a stack of papers where one or two are obvious good, one is controversial that we argue over, and 17 get binned after 5 minutes (the rest if the time you spend on the paper is just to give the authors useful feedback).