Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by just2n on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:28AM
(#5464664)
Unless there is a 100% pass rate, there is definitely "error." Picking someone who you couldn't find a problem with but who is incapable of passing your courses counts as picking the wrong person.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by mtpearce on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:56AM
(#5464707)
The six year completion rate of the 2006 cohort was 95% (http://ucomm.stanford.edu/cds/2012). This rate has been consistent, both over time and at other top schools. Of the 5% that don't complete, it's rare that the student is incapable of completing (aaron swartz, tiger woods, etc). The admissions department will be the first to tell you that they pass on _a lot_ of qualified people. Even though most people believe that they were an 'admissions mistake', I still don't think that 'error' is the right term.
Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by barry-cotter on Saturday March 30, 2013 @02:49AM
(#5464692)
The only elite college in the US with a failure rate higher than 2% is Cal Tech. Everyone else provides ample opportunities to switch to less rigorous majors with lower standards. Given that they're admitting 18 year olds with no previous experience of living away from home they're not realisitically going to approach elite professional school levels of graduation unless they make it really easy to pass.
Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by duaneb on Saturday March 30, 2013 @03:36AM
(#5464771)
Lower standards or a better fit? I would find some subjects, like studio art, prohibitively difficult.
Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by ohazi on Saturday March 30, 2013 @04:01AM
(#5464813)
I went to Caltech for undergrad. I know people who got "burnt out" and switched to non-science majors, but the core curriculum would still require everyone (even an English major) to take quantum mechanics, differential equations, etc. They've made some changes to the core curriculum requirements in the last few years, but I think this is still the case.
Re:Stanford's 2017 acceptance rate hits record low: 5.7%
by aneth4 on Saturday March 30, 2013 @04:05AM
(#5464817)
Even if the admission process had no "error" as you call it, there would still be kids who fail. Future behavior and circumstances are not predictable or controllable to that extent, no matter how good the admissions process is.
Regardless, the goal of admissions is not to pick the exact top students, but to create a solid class. That may involve taking some chances on kids who provide diversity or experience in areas other than pure academics. If those kids fail, it is not error, but intentional risk. Even the "best" (whatever that means) kid carries some risk, and may fail due to personal or incidental circumstances that could not have been known during the admissions process.