That is the opposite of everything I have read about special forces training.
Anyone who makes it past the initial stages is extremely physically fit. The difference between the qualifiers and the rest is in the mind.
What? There are some things beyond your control, but work with smart people on a problem people are willing to pay for on the leading edge of the current wave of technology. Dozens of good and bad things happen randomly--take advantage or weather the storms. Don't fuck up any of the obvious things, and work hard. Do this and you'll get paid.
Now, there's a whole other class of startup where you're betting that in six months, you'll have figured out the magic viral fairy dust that makes 200 million people want to visit your site before the money runs out. You might need some luck.
The first wave of drops is how you describe. It is people that don't have the basic physical performance to continue. This in my perception accounts for a relatively small number of drops due to everyone going through prior screening.
The second wave of drops is very similar to the first, but the root is different. The failures are typically for physical reasons, but the source was mental. A lay thing to say is "He didn't have the heart." These people are typically labeled as "badge hunters" as they are looking for the bravado of the title, but honestly don't enjoy the job itself. The wrong types of motivation will quickly weed themselves out.
Similarly, things like carefully choosing your co-founders, advisors and investors... doing good customer development, understanding your market better than anyone, give you more control over your fate.
Nothing is absolute, but the analogy seems apt to me: You're not a statistic.
Many personal achievements in life are a "complete mystery" to many or most observers, or to science, or to mainstream intellectual discourse, but they still draw on rare and special qualities of individuals. Even if you don't "control" the outcome, that doesn't mean it's not a function of who you are (in the broadest sense).
However, you could have just created a successful startup. You could create an incredible product. You can still fail if Google launches a competing product at the same time before yours can gain traction. You can still fail if someone else comes out with a better and cheaper way to do what you're doing. You can still fail if a key part of your marketing fails you for reasons out of your control (Facebook blocking access to their API).
It's simply a function of the amount of chaos. Nobody can tell you if your startup will succeed or fail. I'm very sure that a special forces instructor will be able to tell if you'll make it after just a few minutes of watching you perform.
So yes, there's a high degree of chaos. This means to succeed you must be all the more resourceful and dogged and/or experienced. Maybe these things are harder to quantify than predictors of success in the special forces. I don't know anything about the special forces. The wording used above just strikes me as true for start-ups rather than being a contrast.
Leadership and team-building abilities are a significant success factor due to peer evaluations. You could be a 0.1%'er in physical ability and still get peered out because no one trusts you or wants you in their squad. Like a startup, your ability to build relationships is key to success.
* Getting demotivated by statistics is the worst possible use of time and energy. It means nothing that the average reader of this comment has various qualities and abilities that, on average, are about average for a reader of this comment. Every reader is an individual, not an average. Start-ups, like people, and marriages, are so different that you just can't generalize across them in very illuminating ways. This is the same as saying there are many subtypes, and at best you could draw comparisons or generalizations within a subtype. Which is the same as saying if you scope your generalizations small enough and choose your points of comparison wisely, you have a chance of capturing a meaningful pattern that might actually tell you something about an individual specimen. Or you might just be over-analyzing.
* It's possible to create causality and attribute events to your actions, even retroactively -- it's called taking responsibility. You can even take responsibility for things you didn't know about, like an executive or official who resigns over misconduct below him. There is very little we have direct control over -- the positions of our limbs, for example, but only when we are paying attention to them -- but we are expected to exercise whatever indirect control we have. People in high positions of power and responsibility have very indirect control -- hiring the right people, putting policies and checks in place -- but they must accept this responsibility and milk it for all it's worth. When you take responsibility for something, you choose to account for (recognize, pay attention to) the causality between you and that thing. We exist in a vast interconnected web of causality, so it's all what you choose to focus on.
This isn't about disposition vs. circumstances, either. Your disposition and circumstances are both different from other people's, as are your goals, motivations, and strategies. It's about how much weight you should give a statistic about other people when trying to determine something about yourself. As you learn more about yourself and the world, and especially if you pursue areas where you are strong, statistics become meaningless.
If you're making decisions, evidence-based decision making can help you decide between different courses of action (A/B testing is an extremely simple example of statistics in action). Statistics can even give you some information about which factors can impact the likelihood of different outcomes. Maybe you think factor Y about your current situation (or your personality, or your product, or whatever) makes some outcome particularly likely. Is that actually true? Sometimes the honest answer is we don't have any way of knowing, because it's a unique situation. But I think people jump to that conclusion far too quickly. Often there is actually considerable information available, if you want to use it. I'd rather use existing data than cultivate some kind of "everything is my decision and I'm in control" mindset, when that would just be delusion in many cases: many things are beyond my control, but some are within it, and I think making effective decisions requires figuring out which is which.
If a certain statistical interpretation is simplistic and naive, the response I'd like to see is a more sophisticated but still evidence-based interpretation. I don't think that "I'm a unique snowflake and I don't need evidence or science because of GRIT" is a good substitute.
When life gets real, there is no comfort in figures. Real (and wonderful) commitments such as marriage and a challenging work environment have taught me that. And the more you excel, the more unusual you become and the more statistics will predict your failure.
In special training, the reasons people are likely to drop out are because they aren't physically fit enough to cope. This gives your a brother a good indication - he likely knows others of similar fitness to him who passed. The key here is that there isn't much randomness involved - either you are fit enough or you aren't.
Startups are a completely different ballgame. The main factors behind dropping out are a complete mystery - team composition, relationships, lucky deals with investors, hitting your marketing in at the same time some other big player pulls out or pitches in - the list is endless and impossible to even fully understand.
Basically what I'm trying to get at is that comparing something you have complete control over (special forces training) vs something you don't (a startup's success) is not a great analogy.
However you're still correct anyway - the best indicator of whether a startup succeeds is whether or not they try in the first place! So it's always best to try and ignore the baseline.