This may all be true, but none of it addresses the huge, sudden, new losses that are being reported in this story:
Annual bee losses of 5 percent to 10 percent once were the norm for beekeepers. But after colony collapse disorder surfaced around 2005, the losses approached one-third of all bees, despite beekeepers’ best efforts to ensure their health.
And even though this poster points out that boutique chemical-free beekeeping exists, he doesn't say that such beekeepers have been spared this blight. I don't know if they have in fact suffered less or not, but you'd think that if they had, that would be both something worth mentioning and kind of a huge clue into whatever degree of mystery the collapse disorder really represents.
And the colony died, randomly. Also happened to some friends' hive. The beekeeper we bought the supplies from hypothesized it was the cold, but we didn't have an unnaturally cold winter and we live in the bay area (not really known for being freezing).
are you sure there's no pesticide on the plants on the lands nearby? that would also explain the CC of your friend's if he lives in the same area
The decline of honey bee since 1947 has nothing to do with the top two points this guys claims. (Removable frames and opening the top)
After WWII, there was a drop off of number of beekeepers. This was due to changing agriculture and the dynamics of the family farm, with a huge surge towards cities and jobs. I will not even try to guess about the down fall of beekeeping due to removable tops, except to say that this is a key point in the narrow minded approach of the Warre hive crowd.
Up till the mid 1980's, beekeeping was healthy and productive. Losing 10% of your hives were considered a bad year. The worst thing that could of happened was getting AFB. (Which by the way was controlled by the removable frame Langstroth hive. AFB prior to removable frames were as high as 50% in some areas, and the basis of most inspection programs years ago. It was a serious matter destroying beekeeping back in it's day. The removable frame (and being able to inspect hives) was why AFB is controlled...even to this day.)
Then we had the introduction of varroa mites, trachea mites, various viral and bacterial issues associated with mites, a new nosema, and now small hive beetle. That does not even scratch the surface in regards to pesticides and the new classes of chemicals out there.
But the Warre crowd sprinkles the conversation with all the key words and talking points, to bash anyone not using a Warre hive, and tailors, or better yet,,,"warps" all information to best fit their ideology.
But how can you claim that the downfall of beekeeping is caused by the Langstroth hive with removable frames and a removable top, and yet claim the root of CCD is chemicals and farming practices. I guess the Warre hive is immune to chemicals. ;)
Anyhow...read the above post. And you can get a sense of the agenda and the promotion of the Warre hive.
not agreeing with either :). but he points that this brought a boost in production not the downfall. later he argue it wasn't sustainable in the longer term. but he never says the introduction of that type of hive start the decline of bees.
----------
So, IMO this is about half true and a lot of it is conjecture or outright tin-foil-hatism….
What he/she says about the screwing around in the hive is at least partly true. But most experienced beekeepers don't go in the hives more than they need to (I've been in mine [I lost one over the winter] twice since like October). This is typically a new-beekeeper phenomenon (and more new beekeepers are not the problem).
The Langstroth hive does allow for more easily managed beekeeping. Top bar hives are en vogue among the hippie beekeeping crowd - they are more common in third world beekeeping. There are even some advantages to them (they are much easier to build, e.g.). Without the Langstroth, there would probably be very very few backyard beekeepers.
Copious fucking with the bees is definitely part of the problem. The largest issue, which the author points out, is all of the bee migration: going out to pollinate almonds in CA, and then blueberries in MI, etc. This is, as they point out, a MUCH bigger business than honey. Honey is a by-product of pollination business. This is only news to non-beekeepers.
Most of the pesticide issues with bees is from bee contact with things NOT used directly by the beekeeper. Bees are extremely sensitive to pesticides. If you are carrying bees all over the place, especially to farmland, you have a higher chance of them interacting with pesticides. But I have a similar risk if one of my neighbors within, say, a mile, decides to pesticide up a plant that is flowering and my bees happen to be using it for food.
Yes, the chemicals used on bees are much like the chemicals used in, say, poultry or beef production. Preventative and abused by overuse. FWIW, I have all the chemicals, but have never treated mine. Treating when it's appropriate is better than letting the bees get sick or overrun by parasites. There is something called IPM (Integrated Pest Management) advocating this kind of appropriate treatment when necessary, along with other non-chemical preventative management. Beekeeper certifications are based on these methods.
There are guidelines to when chemical treatments can occur to keep it out of the honey flow. I'm pretty sure no matter how poorly these treatments are done, any "poisoned" honey is much healthier than any produce you'd get that's ever had pesticides applied to it (or, say, spraying yourself with DEET). Remember bees are _extremely_ sensitive to toxins.
Varroa are the biggest bee pest since they came to the US in the 80s. Again this would only be news to non-beekeepers. They are here to stay and we're now in the business of managing them…there's no getting rid of them entirely and the statement about how humans are spreading them around is a bit disingenuous -- bees are spreading them around just as well. This is the same story as throughout the biological world where an invasive species is introduced via this new thing we call "global travel".
Cell size might be a contributing factor to some things (like mite populations), so I'll let the author have that one.
The hive I lost this winter was FULL of honey (> 10gal). The bees still froze/starved. They were just too weak eventually to maintain temperature and to get to the honey they did have. Bees, given the proper conditions will produce WAY WAY more honey than they need and in fact, leaving it all on there increases the size of the hive they have to maintain, and can weaken their ability to fight off cold, disease, and intruders. Sometimes nature gets the best of the bees. The long warm fall/winter we had left the bees in a more active mode for longer with less incoming food and then the erratic winter didn't help.
I do feed my bees syrup or pollen patties or a combination of the two maybe twice a year. Usually this is just pre-winter to keep them from eating into the valuable honey right next to the hive body before winter or to give them an easier/quick source of food coming out of winter. This is only a supplemental source of food, the bees are almost entirely eating pollen and honey.
The bit about store honey is fairly accurate. I would hesitate to buy honey from a store if I had a better source. I'm not sure about the whole "benefit" thing -- I tend to believe that honey is mostly a simple sugar that isn't all that good for us and I don't buy into the whole eating honey with pollen will stave off allergies claim. I eat it because I like how it tastes, not because it's a health food. So some of that is also granola/hippie handwringing IMO.
BUT HERE'S WHERE THE BIGGEST BS COMES IN: The author's pontification on the cause of CCD. Even if you know nothing about bees, just reading that paragraph sounds like conspiracy paranoia. There are a lot of stressors on bees: parasites, disease, pesticides, commercial migration, etc. CCD, however, is a very specific condition: In simplest terms, the colony just disappears entirely. The latest findings I read about were pointing to a combination of a fungal infection common in bees called Nosema with a secondary cause, perhaps a bacterial infection like Foulbrood or a viral one like Deformed Wing virus. But the truth is we don't know. It's not a conspiracy of government and big business. Newsflash: Also, the moon landing wasn't faked.
My $0.02. Or well this is long enough to be more like $0.10.
(I am quite ready to believe there are cheaters, but if it is more or less industry practice, it should be easy enough to document it)
The guy (in the reddit comment) probably has a point about the filtering and heating (and more broadly, the sourcing and purity of the honey). Tossing it in there with some rabble about other sugars being added makes me wonder if his agenda is one that I would like.
"By the time the FDA said it realized the Chinese honey was tainted, Smuckers had sold 12,040 cases of individually packed honey to Ritz-Carlton Hotels and Sara Lee said it may have been used in a half-million loaves of bread that were on store shelves.
Eventually, some honey packers became worried about what they were pumping into the plastic bears and jars they were selling. They began using in-house or private labs to test for honey diluted with inexpensive high fructose corn syrup or 13 other illegal sweeteners or for the presence of illegal antibiotics. But even the most sophisticated of these tests would not pinpoint the geographic source of the honey."
And then in several other parts of the article it mentions the tainted Chinese honey that has the pollen footprint removed.
It doesn't come out explicitly to say "Chinese honey is tainted and diluted with artificial sweeteners." Because Chinese honey as pointed out in many parts of the article is run through ultra-filtration techniques to eliminate the only foolproof way of eliminating origin, which is the pollen footprint.
So, it could very well be that some of the honey with sweeteners comes from other places, and not from China. But there seems to be a strong link between Chinese practices and the tainted honey, as the article seems to allude to.
Anyway, the paragraph just prior to the two you quote makes it pretty clear that the first paragraph you quote is specifically about antibiotics. And, repeating myself, the notion that packers are testing suppliers is not particularly an impeachment of the honey industry.
I replied to Anigbrowl because their reply was rather terse and this article is not the sort of smoking gun I talked about in my first post.
I replied to lilsunnybee because they imply that I was lazy in my reply, and I wasn't.
Vague allusions to the idea that Chinese honey is sketchy is hardly what I had in mind in my original post. That it doesn't come right out and say anything sort of suggests that they don't really have any documentation that it is happening.
Our only hope is that it's actually a false choice and that human innovation can, at some point in the future, cash the checks we're writing with industrial farming, pollution and others without significant harm to our race. The checks will be cashed either way, it's just a question of how painful that will be.
People live paycheck to paycheck, have children without being prepared, get married without being ready, party every weekend and do things they don't even remember, destroy their bodies with chemicals, treat their fellow man with little to no regard, eat garbage, refuse to exercise, get less than required amount of sleep, sit on the couch and watch TV for consecutive hours at a time.
What are the results? Divorce, suicide, diabetes, cancer, obesity, high blood pressure, heart disease, murder, rape, bankruptcy, debt, family feuds, domestic violence, child abuse, homelessness.
This planet is temporary.
I like this one. Probably meant Nestduftwärmebindung (Nest=nest Duft=scent Wärme=warmth Bindung=binding).
Actually, without the movable frame system hives wouldn't have much of a chance to survive (At least in our part of Germany). My only hive died this winter, because there was too much honey in it. When the hive cools down to the lower 20°C range in winter the honey crystallizes and becomes too hard for the bees to eat. If done properly, taking the honey and feeding the right syrup (which is not just sugar and water) will keep them alive, as it doesn't crystallize.
I'm quite sure the cell foundation you get in here are of natural size and I have not experienced any problems with the bees building natural combs for drones. Here again the frame system is just great for helping the hive: It allows for the drone combs to be removed after the cells have been sealed, which reduces Varroa, as these prefer drones as hosts.
Another considerable advantage of Langstroth vs. classical skeps: You don't have to kill the hive to get honey/wax. Plus you get pure honey and not some honey - dead bee - crushed larvae - coctail.
Interestingly enough I found that comment after going way down through the comments of this article yesterday: http://news.sciencemag.org/sciencenow/2013/03/bees-buzz-each...
I thought, awesome trivia knowledge! And now my comment foraging is extremely relevant to a post today.
Ok, Hacker News regular, non-redditor here. I've got no horse in the reddit race, but I do know my Hacker News and here is the sad truth: reddit is responsible for the decline of the world-wide Hacker News community for the last (roughly) 6 years, and for the precipitous decline since 2012.
Commenting as it has been done since the widespread adoption of the reddit has been bad for Hacker News. This is mostly because the reddit has lots of posers and trolls who talk when they should listen. These newbies led to highly interventionist commenting, and copious fucking with serious community members.
The web-based interface allows the commenter to easily troll, hate, argue, and pontificate, and led to migratory community hopping. Threads are now trucked by the tens of thousands of uniques across the internet with the seasons for the community forum business (which is a bigger than the software business). The results is that viruses and on-line pests move too. The biggest community killer in the US right now is the stepfather, introduced from reddit by trollers in 2012, and spread by anonymous users to communities across the web.
The opening of the web destroys pg's carefully maintained arc application, the HN atmosphere. Posters maintain a anti-microbial discussion inside the forum, at a contant atmosphere with a complex culture. They can go into fever-mode, raising the temp to kill off trollers. The software helps maintain communication and defenses. Opening the community destroys the atmosphere. It takes the moderators days to reestablish, and is a costly expense of energy they need for debugging, troubleshooting, and scaling for eternal September. This weakens the users, compromising their karma system and leaving them susceptible to spammers and hackers.
Then there's language wars. Developers spend all season building tools so that they can survive the bubble burst. The troller comes along and takes it, then feeds the devs javascript on the server. This also weakens the infrastructure. Software is a complex, nutritious business food. Frameworks are simple, inadequate food. This is something like you farming all season and stocking up for the winter. You've canned and preserved your veg, and filled your freezer with meat, ready for the hard, unproductive winter. Then someone comes along, takes all your food, and replaces it with Twinkies. You'll survive the winter on Twinkies, but you'll be in pretty bad health come spring. (Although, like the programmers with frameworks, you'll happily eat the Twinkies, because, yum.)
In the pursuit of larger karma harvest, trollers have been artificially increasing the size if the comment thread for about 4 years, by using friends. Voting rings are thought to mean more karma. So the nicks you see today (with some exceptions) are "karma-whore" users, bigger than the community made them. Higher karma means the users are too big and the lurkers are too small (members left on their own will make different sized comments for each type of thread). This weakens the community. Some programmers bred generations on frameworks have lost their ability to create software on their own.
These weak, immuno-compromised devs are then protected by the community with fluff and drama placed in the forum to deal with the spammers and trollers that the moderators can no longer fight off. This poisons the community (yum!) and the members, and encourages resistant trolls.
Reddit is also dominated by artificial breeding of drama queens, which eliminates the Darwinian battle of the commenters which nature uses to find the strongest poster. This weakens the genetics of the members, for thousands of generations. Most, in fact almost all, web forums are industrial trolling, equivalent to factory trolling Facebook or twitter. And it has devastated the community.
There are exceptions: look into Ask HN posts (which come from legitimate users except once a day); YC related news, and anything from patio11. (taken from the surplus after he's done blogging).
A note about karma: most of the karma you get on Hacker News is not. It is sheeplike and filtered and wisdom-free, removing the extraordinary health benefits of subject matter experts, cut with antecdotes, suppositions or other non sequitors, and laced with drama and bullshit. If you want karma, make unfiltered, unheated obsevations, from a hacker you know. If you want karma and are concerned about voting rings, post when most users are present and trollers are busy at reddit. A note about Community Collapse Disorder: CCD is not a mystery, as is often reported. CCD is caused by industrial trolling and posing, which destroy real hackers' cerebral abilities, and they can't find their way back to the data. The whole "it's mysterious" thing is a lie promoted by the fluff communities, primarily reddit. But in the context of forums weakened by generations of industrial trolling, trying to forage on thousands of threads of popculture posts, having been FTP'd thousands of links from their home url, it is an easy lie to sell.
---------------
Ok, beekeeper, non-vegan here. I've got no horse in the vegan race, but I do know my bees and here is the sad truth: beekeeping is responsible for the decline of world-wide bee population for the last (roughly) 150 years, and for the precipitous decline since 1947.
Beekeeping as it has been done since the widespread adoption of the Langstroth hive has been bad for bees. This is mostly because the hive design has movable frames and opens from the top. These innovations led to highly interventionist beekeeping, and copious fucking with the bees.
The movable frame allows the beekeeper to easily remove, inspect, replace, and swap comb, and led to migratory beekeeping. Bees are now trucked by the tens of thousands of hives across the country with the seasons for the pollination business (which is a bigger than the honey business). The results is that diseases and bee pests move too. The biggest colony killer in the US right now is the Varroa mite, introduced from Asia by humans in 1988, and spread by humans to hives across the country.
The opening from the top destroys the bees' carefully maintained nestduftwarmebingdung, the nest atmosphere. Bees maintain a anti-microbial sauna inside the hive, at a contant tempurature with a complex scent. They can go into fever-mode, raising the temp to kill off infection. The scent helps maintain communication and defenses. Opening the hive destroys the atmosphere. It takes the bees days to reestablish, and is a costly expense of energy they need for foraging, building, and preparing for winter. This weakens the bees, compromising their immune system and leaving them susceptible to infection and invaders.
Then there's honey. Bees spend all season making honey stores so that they can survive the winter. The beekeeper comes along and takes it, then feeds the bees sugar syrup in the winter. This also weakens the bees. Honey is a complex, nutritious bee food. Sugar water is a simple, inadequate food. This is something like you farming all season and stocking up for the winter. You've canned and preserved your veg, and filled your freezer with meat, ready for the hard, unproductive winter. Then someone comes along, takes all your food, and replaces it with Twinkies. You'll survive the winter on Twinkies, but you'll be in pretty bad health come spring. (Although, like the bees with sugar, you'll happily eat the Twinkies, because, yum.)
In the pursuit of larger honey harvest, beekeepers have been artificially increasing the size if the bee's comb cell for about 100 years, by using comb foundation. Bigger cells is thought to mean more honey. So the bees you see today (with some exceptions) are "large-cell" bees, bigger than nature made them. Bigger cells means the workers are too big and the drones are too small (bees left on their own will make different sized cells for each type of bee). This weakens the bees. Some bees bred generations on foundation have lost their ability to create comb on their own.
These weak, immuno-compromised bees are then protected by the beekeepers with pesticides and anti-biotics placed in the hive to deal with the disease and pests that the bees can no longer fight off. This poisons the honey (yum!) and the bees, and breeds resistant pests.
Beekeeping is also dominated by artificial breeding of queens, which eliminates the Darwinian battle of the queens which nature uses to find the strongest queen. This weakens the genetics of the bees, for thousands of generations. Most, in fact almost all, beekeeping is industrial farming, equivalent to factory farming chickens or cattle. And it has devastated the bees.
There are exceptions: look into vertical top bar hives (which open from the bottom except once a year); chemical-free beekeeping; and spring-harvest honey (taken from the surplus after winter is over).
A note about honey: most of the honey you buy at the grocery store is not. It is heated and filtered and pollen-free, removing the extraordinary health benefits of honey, cut eith corn syrup, beet syrup or other sweeteners, and laced with pesticides and anti-biotics. If you want honey, buy unfiltered, unheated honey, from a beekeeper you know. If you want honey and are concerned about the bees, buy from a beekeeper using Warré topbar hives, doing a surplus harvest. A note about Colony Collapse Disorder: CCD is not a mystery, as is often reported. CCD is caused by industrial farming pesticides, which destroy bees' navigational abilities, and they can't find their way back to the hive. The whole "it's mysterious" thing is a lie promoted by the chemical companies, primarily Bayer. But in the context of bees weakened by generations of industrial beekeeping, trying to forage on thousands of acres of monoculture crops, having been trucked thousands of miles from their home territory, it is an easy lie to sell.
---------------
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/wsx2q/after_midni...