News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ron Garret: How knowing Lisp destroyed my programming car... by asciilifeform on Saturday April 04, 2009 @12:45AM (#546085)
>Lisp has no monopoly on elegance or "metaprogramming"

Lisp (or rather, the Lisp family - the word has not referred to a specific programming language for decades) does have a monopoly on programming by way of raw syntax tree entry. The latter appears to be required for a proper macro system (though David Moon and others have attempted to change this.)

The fact is, I feel caged when I am programming in a language where I cannot monkey with the syntax at will, and I am not alone in this feeling. When I am barred from creating new syntactic constructs, I feel like a "human compiler" (in fact, exactly that which the job title "programmer" actually meant in practice before the invention of actual compilers.)

I wish to branch out to languages which feel less limiting and more general than the Lisps, not otherwise. And I have yet to encounter any. All of the good ideas of Haskell (laziness, etc.) are easily bolted on top of even a stock Common Lisp. Likewise for the other languages named. Forth, however, remains interesting due to its AK47-like simplicity and embeddability.

Re:Ron Garret: How knowing Lisp destroyed my programming car... by dmoney on Saturday April 04, 2009 @09:35AM (#546306)
I feel like a "human compiler" (in fact, exactly that which the job title "programmer" actually meant in practice before the invention of actual compilers.)

[citation needed]

Re:Ron Garret: How knowing Lisp destroyed my programming car... by asciilifeform on Saturday April 04, 2009 @12:27PM (#546411)
Read a history of Fortran. It was originally meant for a human to compile into machine code.
Re:Ron Garret: How knowing Lisp destroyed my programming car... by frig on Saturday April 04, 2009 @10:27AM (#546323)
APL/J/K/Q fit the bill. The Larrabee instruction set is like a pipedream for old APL(and similar)-ers.

Edit: for the unfamiliar, http://ed-thelen.org/comp-hist/APL-hist.html .

Edit: and for the other side: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_APL_programmin...

Re:Ron Garret: How knowing Lisp destroyed my programming car... by MaysonL on Saturday April 04, 2009 @03:24PM (#546577)
A money quote, from your first link:

Here's what I did. For a set of problems, of increasing difficulty, I would write a solution procedure, using the notation of A Programming Language I would then ask the graduate student assigned to me to:

program the procedure in any programming language he chose,

execute the procedure for a representative set of data values

give me his program and answers so that I could compare them with the specifications I had written and the answers I had previously calculated.

The result, which I still find surprising and impressive, was: In every case, what was programmed was exactly what I specified.