There's a balance to be struck. You need to be hungry enough to viciously attack new problems, yet not so hungry that they become an obsessive end in themselves.
This poses an interesting, and very difficult, question to answer: how do you know whether something learned now will be useful in the future, especially if few other seem particularly interested? Over time you might develop an intuition for which things seem like they would be useful, but I can't imagine such an intuition would be perfect.
There is a certain amount of one's desire to learn that is a matter of personality, and my understanding is that there is some degree of a person's personality that is determined by things other than socialization. Not all of it, but enough to possibly make a difference.
The flip-side of this is that if there are people who, due to some or another in-born trait, are unable to cultivate an attitude of continued hunger for knowledge, that is something they need to deal with by not entering into a profession that demands it. And programming is definitely one of those fields.
EDIT: silencing my own inner grammar nazi
Yes, I agree. (I upvoted the comment.)
A full response to this will take longer than I have right now (maybe I'll work on a blog entry later tonight). But for now, just for the record, my problem was definitely not that I was unwilling to learn new things. I love learning new things, and always have.
> I learned more in my one year at Google than in the previous thirty.
This actually makes sense. It's not about being curious, it's about what you're curious about. I remember once asking one of my friends a very basic question about ring theory (whether a certain ring axiom is overly strong.) He completely refused to consider the problem, because it didn't seem relevant. That's not a lack of curiosity, just a lack of curiosity about irrelevant questions, and math is all about knowing which questions to ask. It's not like you learn nothing by solving the problem, just not anything you would have ever wanted to know.
The reaction I had to this was primarily due to me seeing in this post the stories of countless other developers who stagnate but then don't have the self-reflection to realize that they have, and don't have the motivation to get themselves out of the hole they've fallen into. While attempting to motivate the Lisp community to wake up and get working, in my mind you unintentionally created an anthem to all of them. Hopefully my initial response to this makes a little more sense. :-)
Whether a statement is true or false is independent of what it encourages. Let's assume that curiosity is totally hard-wired. Then is it really a good thing for someone to try to become more curious, instead of investing that effort into something else?
Neuroplasticity FTW. The human brain is a most adaptable tool.
But that said, how many infants are 'incurious'? They either are curious, or there is something wrong with them. No baby is incurious without some kind of pathology.
The major point I got from this article is that you can't stop being hungry for knowledge and expect not to get beat by those who are. The language didn't matter; he got bested by the people who kept learning and exploring while he decided he had learned "enough" for one lifetime. He made the mistake of making it about those around him; he didn't want to continually improve, just better than those he would be compared with. He went from learning just enough to best people, to being smug, to being a curmudgeon against other languages/platforms/etc he professed to not know a lot about. I keep seeing evidence around me that this is a very counter-productive shortcut to take, but one that most people don’t own up to; props to him for being honest, but sad that it took him too long to come to reason about it. In an odd way, I see this same pattern of behavior in a lot of the one-language-wonder Java programmers I meet today; they know Java, and find what reasons they can to declare that all other languages suck.
So, your point about libraries is a good one, but I’d amend your remarks to advise cultivating an attitude toward development that makes using libraries and ideas of others almost instinctual, and that, I think, is by making sure you always stay hungry for knowledge.