News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 28, 2013 @09:40PM (#5458788)
It is unlikely the IRS would need a new law to require Americans to report significant Bitcoin positions on their returns.

If you have a stack of cash in a drawer, you are supposed to tell the IRS about it. It does not matter if it's in dollars, yen, Swiss francs, or pounds sterling. The fact that a lot of people don't doesn't make it legal, just unlikely to be enforced unless you give the IRS a reason to hate you. If, on the other hand, you have a garage with millions of dollars of un-reported cash in it you become an IRS priority. This is no different, under present law, from someone holding millions of dollars in bitcoins across several wallets.

The IRS could also treat bitcoins as an asset, which would classify bitcoin transactions as barter and make holdings subject to capital gains (and losses) in dollar terms. All said, it would not need new legislation to deal with this.

Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by andrewpi on Thursday March 28, 2013 @11:06PM (#5459035)
> If you have a stack of cash in a drawer, you are supposed to tell the IRS about it.

Under what regulation?

Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by n3rdy on Thursday March 28, 2013 @11:21PM (#5459077)
> Under what regulation?

Unfortunately when it comes to the IRS, current laws and regulations are irrelevant. They prosecute retroactively and change the rules as they see fit to scare the public into compliance.

The fact that people are so quick to ask about IRS compliance with bitcoins is evidence of this. People feel an obligation to an entity they owe nothing to, because they are scared to death if they don't report a couple bitcoins, that FBI, secret service, or even ATF is going to break down their door and storm in with assault rifles.

Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by gamblor956 on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:53AM (#5459456)
Stop spreading FUD. That's not how the IRS operates. It very frequently loses court cases, including Tax Court cases, in which the taxpayer challenges IRS actions.

More to the point--the IRS does not have police powers, it can only levy civil sanctions after full due process. That means no ATF involvement, ever. The IRS can, in limited circumstances, refer cases to the DOJ for further investigation as a criminal matter.

Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by oleganza on Friday March 29, 2013 @10:18AM (#5460828)
In other words, there are frequently cases in which IRS tries to take what does not belong to them? If so, it only proves the point that people are scared by IRS and it is IRS that spreads soul-killing FUD.
Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by cantankerous on Thursday March 28, 2013 @11:16PM (#5459062)
If it's a heretofore unreported accession to wealth, that regulation would be the US Tax Code.
Re:Do you have to file an FBAR for a bitcoin account? by gamblor956 on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:49AM (#5459438)