Re:Judge Says Mathematical Algorithms Can’t Be Patented
by sthu11182 on Thursday March 28, 2013 @05:55PM
(#5457930)
I think the most interesting thing right now at the Federal Circuit is the complete change in make up of the judges. I think President Obama has or will have appointed half of the court. In 2009, Justice Roberts stated at the Supreme Court during oral arguments for a non-Federal Circuit case, "Well, they don't have a choice, right? They can't say, I don't like the Supreme Court rule so I'm not going to apply it, other than the Federal Circuit." The Federal Circuit is not regularly being overturned any more and that may be a reflection of the new court (just a guess here).
I think some of the recent cases on reasonable royalty show a Federal Circuit trying to reform the system a little bit.
Re:Judge Says Mathematical Algorithms Can’t Be Patented
by a_p on Thursday March 28, 2013 @06:28PM
(#5458093)
>I think President Obama has or will have appointed half of the court.
"Will have appointed" has taken on a new meaning during this presidency. The Circuit Court currently has 16 vacancies, and 6 "Judicial Emergencies",[1] meaning that there are too many cases for current judges to handle. Although Obama has made fewer nominations at this point than his predecessors, this shortage is largely because Senate Republicans hate Obama and refuse to confirm his nominations — ability of litigants to have their cases heard be damned.
[1] http://www.afj.org/judicial-selection/judicial-selection-sna...
Re:Judge Says Mathematical Algorithms Can’t Be Patented
by triplesec on Saturday March 30, 2013 @09:01AM
(#5465272)
Well, technically, they hate science, they hate careful discourse, and they hate themselves for being very stupid, but psychologically won't admit that and they need an object to project these feelings onto, so Obama becomes the instantiation of their bogeyman. But all points agreed with!
So here is the problem. People on Hacker News and Reddit will complain. But people at Google, Microsoft, Oracle, etc, keep filing tons of patents. From the perspective of judges and Congressmen, it seems from the outside that everything is fine (every industry, of course, has its discontents).
That's the basic problem--until you can get the big players on board, nothing will change. The Federal Circuit has its biases, but it's not necessarily a "pro patent" bias. Instead, its a pro-Big Science bias. There's nobody on the Federal Circuit from a startup background, but there are judges who used to be engineers and scientists at DuPont, Monsanto, etc. Engineers in Big Science have a different view on patents than startup folks. Their big worries are stuff like: if the Chinese blatantly rip off our technology, can we fight them in the ITC? They don't care about frivolous patent law suits, because a few million dollars here and there isn't even a drop in their legal budgets. This is not a value judgment, it's a description of the state of affairs: the balancing that seems reasonable between defending real innovation from copying and protecting small companies from frivolous lawsuits seems very different when engineering as you know it is Dow, DuPont, etc, than when it's Rackespace, Redhat, etc.