Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by hsmyers on Thursday March 28, 2013 @02:57PM
(#5456922)
It occurs to me that what is needed is a possibly grass roots level approach to the patent problem. If ever there was a good use of the Rico Act this would be the one. And know I'm not a lawyer but how is PT (patent trolling) any different from the mob activities that Rico was designed to help eliminate. This would among other things allow asset forfeiture before the fact---something that would be particularly satisfying in this instance :) Just sayin/daydreamin ...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by rayiner on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:41PM
(#5457157)
The RICO act pertains to threats of illegal force. Filing a lawsuit to vindicate legal rights is not illegal force, by definition. Filing a totally frivolous lawsuit can get an attorney and his client sanctioned, but while something like this may seem frivolous to you it's not legally frivolous (they have a validly-issued patent that has arguably been infringed).
Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by misnome on Thursday March 28, 2013 @02:59PM
(#5456933)
> And know I'm not a lawyer but how is PT (patent trolling) any different from the mob activities that Rico was designed to help eliminate
Patent trolling doesn't generally kill people or traffic drugs.
Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by jfoutz on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:32PM
(#5457110)
Diverting resources to fend off million dollar lawsuits certainly could kill people. It's not only interfering with defendants, but the court system must also redirect resources away from other activities to handle these cases.
If nothing else, hundreds of thousands of hours of effort go into cases like these. Patent reform wouldn't necessarily save a single life, but it would clearly save hundreds of hours of life for thousands of people.
Of course, none of that above relates to RICO
Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by freehunter on Thursday March 28, 2013 @03:07PM
(#5456983)
That's true. Rico has been extended to handle things far outside it's original scope though, so taking the extended definition I could see it work.
Re:Mathematics Cannot be Patented. Case Dismissed
by DannyBee on Thursday March 28, 2013 @05:13PM
(#5457672)
Already tried ...
http://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/patent/manufacturers-atte...