Re:The problems with url shorteners
by MichaelApproved on Friday April 03, 2009 @05:15PM
(#545611)
As a user the most frustrating part isn't waiting for the page to load (due to the third party) but just not knowing where I'm going. URLs have gone from being cryptic to being titled seo/human friendly to cryptic again. I like knowing the title of an article before I click on it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
This is why I implemented url following on the server in Mibbit...
Having someone throw you a shortened url on IRC is a pain, so now the Mibbit server follows it, and sends over the destination URL, which shows when you hover over the shortened URL.
Means a few less surprises ;)
I've seen a couple of other sites do something similar, although it's usually an (expand) thing you have to click.
Well done. A creative solution, well-implemented.
Re:The problems with url shorteners
by TweedHeads on Saturday April 04, 2009 @03:30PM
(#546582)
Perfect, that's what everybody should do, just replace the unreadable cryptic shortener with "link" and follow the url so hovering will show it on the status bar.
I hate not knowing where a link will take me.
Well, for our site, tinyarro.ws, all URLs are all automatically previewed so you have a chance to decide. So if you can get over clicking silly unicode URLs, you should feel more comfortable. http://➔.ws/this
I'm a big fan of informed consent, and I don't understand why the other URL shrinkers don't do opt-out previewing rather than requiring people to track down some mysterious preview cookie or preview URL syntax.
One reason other URL shrinkers don't do opt-out previewing is because it defeats the purpose of the shrinker being convinient. For instance, I use bit.ly's plugin in my Gmail inbox. In two clicks, my URL is shrunk and pasted wherever I want it. If I had an automatic preview of the page, it would take longer to load, making the shrinking process less convenient.
True, but it is entirely opt-out with a single click. So it doesn't have to be there-- but for your clickers they can decide for themselves what they prefer.
neat idea - but I open links and as they load look elsewhere - meaning I entirely miss your inbetween page.
you're solving a problem you made. want a medal?
We didn't make the problem. We're just having fun with silly URL hacks and giving people something fun to show their friends. While we're at it, we're trying to do it the best way we know how.
Good comeback.
There's always the choice not to participate in some activity.
Among other things, that would have solved the Great Depression, World War I, and Germany's hyperinflation in the thirties. Also AIDS.
Re:The problems with url shorteners
by spinchange on Saturday April 04, 2009 @12:02AM
(#546041)
Yep, Linkrot is right up there.
This comment suggests you don't understand my point. Which is basically that people will act in their own individual interest even when its obvious that if everyone does the same thing, bad things are the inevitable result.
Re:The problems with url shorteners
by commenthere on Friday April 03, 2009 @07:41PM
(#545848)
this comment is unbelieveably snarky, if it were anyone other than joshu I have a feeling they'd be at -4 right now, not +4. Would you really say "want a medal?" in person. I doubt it.
You've obviously never met me.
I almost always use tinyurl for that reason since I can enter a descriptive name.
The descriptive ones are nice. http://tinyurl.com/Do-Tiny-URLs-Suck gives a little more information than http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=545565
Well, it's different information. It is nice to know what it's about, but I'd rather read a random news.ycombinator link than a random article titled "Do Tiny URLs Suck".
I wouldn't. I like HN, but any random link could be one of a thousand topics I don't care about.
Re:The problems with url shorteners
by bradgessler on Friday April 03, 2009 @11:36PM
(#546021)
I wrote shorty (http://github.com/bradgessler/shorty/tree/master), installed it on heroku.com, and hooked my own URL up to it so I could enter concise, descriptive shortened URLs. Its not for Joe Shmoe but if you're a geek, check it out.
descriptive doesn't help with malicious intent
Really, it makes that problem worse. I've had it burned into my brain what a shortened URL looks like - short domain, short hash - so I can immediately recognize one and be suspicious of it. But looking at http://tinyurl.com/Do-Tiny-URLs-Suck, I may just click without realizing what it actually is.