Re:Users of my iOS Game Teach Me a Lesson MIT Didn’t (2011)
by bentcorner on Thursday March 28, 2013 @12:20PM
(#5455747)
The completionist in me doesn't like the star system. I feel like I'm being punished for being "dumb". (I stopped playing "Feed Me Oil" because I couldn't figure out the optimal solution to a level.)
Common things to grade with stars:
Speed
fewest 'widgets' to solve
total 'impact' (Think damage a la angry birds)
etc.
We can also combine these sorts of things in the rating system. There is a great game, "Cargo-Bot", that is essentially a programming game. The rating system there only takes into account the number of instructions used but it could do something where it takes into account the number of instructions used and the run time of the "program" produced.
I guess my point is, designing games with singular solutions is probably cheating the gamer out of some additional fun (go back and finish on hard) and cheating the designer out of exploring some interesting concepts around "scoring".