Re:Bacteria in the Intestines May Help Tip the Bathroom Scal...
by cromulent on Thursday March 28, 2013 @07:00AM
(#5454149)
I'll bite.
Net caloric balance is an important predictor, but not the sole predictor. That's why it "drives people nuts" - because it is not true.
For example:
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn23127-abnormal-gut-bac...
Re:Bacteria in the Intestines May Help Tip the Bathroom Scal...
by Daniel_Newby on Thursday March 28, 2013 @08:34AM
(#5454394)
> saying "net caloric balance is the sole predictor of long term average body mass" drives people nuts
Because it is like saying that fuel combustion causes car crashes. And then smugly congratulating yourself about how you have solved a major public health problem by prescribing a fuel shortage.
> It's just as possible that different microbial populations follow from obesity.
In which case transplanting the skinny microbes to a stout animal would make no difference. The research in question shows it does.
It's just as possible that different microbial populations follow from obesity.
Actually, it seems more likely that this is the case, given that the populations change after band surgery.
And, as always, there is no biological mechanism so far discovered that transcends the conservation of energy and matter.
Given how hilariously silly any thread on diet becomes on HN (because for some reason saying "net caloric balance is the sole predictor of long term average body mass" drives people nuts), I believe I will sit this out to avoid getting a severe case of XKCD386.