Re:Killing hackers is justified in cyber warfare, says NATO-...
by pekk on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:54PM
(#5450523)
Is a man sitting in a bomber a combatant? If so, then how is a drone pilot not a combatant?
How does international law protect civilians in a war, except by the actions of a party interested in protecting those civilians?
Re:Killing hackers is justified in cyber warfare, says NATO-...
by kiiski on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @02:00PM
(#5450973)
"And this reduces the protections international law has for his house and the civilians within ( his family)."
I don't know what protections you are talking about, but I doubt the pilots would be piloting anything from their homes. They only go there on leave, just like all other soldiers. As for hackers, if a state sponsored attack is launched from a civilian home, it is a violation of the rules of war. The hackers should be in a military installation when doing anything (they probably would anyway, just for security, easier cooperation etc.). There has always been soldiers who fight wars without going to the battlefield.
Re:Killing hackers is justified in cyber warfare, says NATO-...
by yk on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @03:52PM
(#5451588)
The scenario I am thinking about is, that bombing an apartment block full of civilians is quite clearly a war crime. On the other hand, bombing barracks is not. And since a drone pilot on leave is as far as I understand still a combatant, he can be attacked given that the harm to civilians is 'proportional.' [1]
Re:Killing hackers is justified in cyber warfare, says NATO-...
by stcredzero on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @04:15PM
(#5451720)
Also, it should be possible to give drones even more selective weapons:
https://share.sandia.gov/news/resources/news_releases/bullet...
So I think, that the dominant military power ( or in case of the NATO, military alliance) should try to limit the use of potentially disruptive developments, already out of self interest.
[1] I will not argue in this about the morality of war or the logic of warfare. Here I will simply argue within this framework.