News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by 3am on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @11:33AM (#5449987)
I hate cloud headlines. What's the hypervisor? VMWare is a hypervisor (ESX) and management applications (vCenter/vSphere, vCloud Director, etc). Openstack is only the management applications. And VMWare contributes the most interesting part of OpenStack, anyway, which is the virtual networking based on Nicira's OpenFlow.

My personal experience with OpenStack (admittedly late Diablo release timeframe) was that it was borderline unusable outside of the developer setup of a standalone node on Ubuntu 11.4 backed with KVM (edit: and that was only Nova/Compute, not even including Swift/Storage).

Anyway, very interested to see if this is KVM, Xen, or something else backed. Also very interested to see when they reverse their decision (probably after VMWare comes down on pricing by 10-20 percent).

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by sc68cal on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:12PM (#5450244)
>What's the hypervisor?

OpenStack supports multiple hypervisors. They are implemented as drivers - and are in this part of the OpenStack codebase:

https://github.com/openstack/nova/tree/master/nova/virt/

See my slides from a talk I did yesterday.

https://github.com/sc68cal/openstack-theory-and-practice-pre...

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by 3am on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:15PM (#5450265)
I know this, I'm asking which one of the supported hypervisors Paypal planned on using in their deployment.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by easytiger on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @02:01PM (#5450981)
Then they should say that. Reading their website tells me their are doing that bullshit thing were they divorce the tech from the marketing completely.

> OpenStack is a cloud operating system that controls large pools of compute, storage, and networking resources throughout a datacenter, all managed through a dashboard that gives administrators control while empowering their users to provision resources through a web interface.

Should it (??) really say :

> Openstack is a ton of scripts and tools and things which pull lots of various bits of software together and allow you to have redeployable virtual machines all over the place

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by tsmith on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @05:07PM (#5452022)
Almost definitely KVM. The Ubuntu/KVM/OpenStack combo is the bread-and-butter deployment scenario outside of a small number of folks (notably Rackspace, which is OpenStack on XenServer^TM).

Also, <= Diablo and to a large extent Essex releases were known to be (politely speaking) less-than-usable OOTB. Folsom was really the first release that could properly be called usable for a production IaaS, and Grizzly is even better.

Source: knowing these things is my job.

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by 3am on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @06:04PM (#5452298)
Many thanks for the info. I had a hell of a time trying^H^H^H^H^H^Hfailing to get Diablo working with XenServer, too. No ill will towards the project, and glad to hear it's maturing. It seemed to be in relatively good hands with Rackspace.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by hkolk on Thursday March 28, 2013 @07:16AM (#5454197)
Hmm, eBay has worked extensively with rackspace for cloud-platforming though, so I think it's mostly Xen: http://www.rackspace.com/knowledge_center/case-study/an-open... http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/11/08/03/0219230/ebay-dep...
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by anotherjesse on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:02PM (#5450181)
The Diablo version was the first version that really combined the projects. Before Diablo each system had its own auth/user system, api style, ...

We've come a long way in 2 years :) Redhat (EPEL/Fedora) and Ubuntu now have built-in packages that are much more solid.

That said, the way to think about OpenStack is like you think about the linux kernel. Most people want a distro, not raw source to setup their environments. Over the last couple years we've seen real advances in distros.

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by 3am on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:11PM (#5450240)
I've kept up a little on OpenStack since then and know people that work with the technology. I'm sure the keystone integrated auth system (or whatever it's called now) really improved things, and it seems like people are making really progress with pushbutton deployments using the usual config/orchestration suspects. Congrats!

That said I know more people would would be content to manage ESX with ovftool or some homebrew solution w/ the soap api than I do who would be willing to use the linux kernel without the usual userspace tools.

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by rektide on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @02:25PM (#5451118)

  I know more people would would be content to manage ESX with ovftool or some homebrew solution w/ the soap api
I for one am not content relying on someone else to manage all of our management tools. On that grounds, love hearing interesting news about OpenStack, CloudStack, Docker.io, or any project which releases open code purporting to helps us all to manage our many nodes, real and virtual.

  without usual userspace tools
As for the unusual "without usual userspace tools" criteria you added, I literally have no idea what you are talking about.

OpenStack is a bunch of code that runs in an OS, there's nothing nearly so magical or different about an OpenStack node as you imply. Do whatever you feel is best for your host nodes.

I install Debian packages on the host and manage it with many of the same tools used to manage it's images. It looks very much like the same usual "just a boring usual Linux node" node I log in to. http://wiki.debian.org/OpenStack

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by viraptor on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @12:51PM (#5450493)
What do you mean by "linux kernel without the usual userspace tools"? Openstack runs on a complete system with all the tools you want to install, not some bare kernel machine.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by 3am on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @04:02PM (#5451644)
"OpenStack is like you think about the linux kernel. Most people want a distro, not raw source to setup their environments"

Since he was comparing the relationship between a hypervisor and Openstack to that between the Linux kernel and the userspace tools, and I was just commenting on that comparison. That is, which I know people that use hypervisors without Openstack (or other virtualization management applications like Cloudstack or vCenter), I don't know anyone that uses the kernel on its own. Sorry, I thought that was clear but I guess it was not.

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by aliguori on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @03:13PM (#5451401)
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by insaneirish on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @01:15PM (#5450645)
> And VMWare contributes the most interesting part of OpenStack, anyway, which is the virtual networking based on Nicira's OpenFlow.

Agree with you about the headline. However, VMWare is not contributing Nicira for free. There just happens to be a Quantum plugin for Nicira (as there is for pretty much everything else).

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by superuser2 on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @02:27PM (#5451133)
Rackspace Cloud Servers runs on OpenStack. It seems to work pretty well for them.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by samstave on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @03:11PM (#5451387)
I would expect that it maybe heavily custom/staffed-up-to-be-configured-for-their-infra

I.E. - it likely didn't just work pretty well for them out of the box.

There is a difference between using a base technology which requires you have FTEs on staff to maintain it and grabbing an off-the-shelf app to help run your systems.

Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by briffle on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @10:25PM (#5453096)
They are one of the two core companies that founded openstack, based on what they needed to run internally. It was rackspace and Nasa.
Re:Paypal To Drop VMware From 80,000 Servers and Replace It ... by vegasbrianc on Thursday March 28, 2013 @04:44AM (#5453806)
Isn't the idea of Open Source technologies? Customizing software for your particular use?