News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by gordaco on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @10:08AM (#5449432)
I just knew that the first two were going to be the Monty Hall problem and 0.99999...==1. I'm actually surprised that so many people don't accept that last one; I understood it immediately when I learned it (I was 12).

The third blows your mind until you realize that, simply put, infinity is not a number and common arithmetic doesn't apply.

The sixth is not really math, although it perplexes a lot of people. I remember that a few years ago my sister didn't get that, if searching for "termX" wouldn't yield any results, searching for "termX and termY" also wouldn't give anything, no matter how much "termY" would.

I'd never seen the 8th, but it's beautiful, and very simple too! Does it really confuse people? Maybe I'm too mathy, but it's obvious to me.

The 9th one is a classic, but I feel it's less "controversial" because if you know (or have been told) that the series diverge, chances are that you have a relatively solid base of mathematical knowledge.

I encountered the 11th in a list of geometry problems recently; I had to prove it. The first time I saw the problem, just before starting a geometry course, I didn't have a clue. I shitted my pants thinking that I was going to fail the course if my exam was like that! Then, after a few weeks of study, I came back and immediately saw the proof, without thinking much (you just have to use the intercept theorem: each side of the parallelogram is parallel to one original polygon's diagonal).

The 7th and the last one don't seem too different than the Monty Hall... our brains are not very well wired for probability estimation and you can see that in many situations.

The rest are nice pieces of pop math (if you feel that "pop math" is not much of an oxymoron, anyway).

Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by alok-g on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @05:28PM (#5452115)
>> 0.99999...==1

I am one of the people who don't accept the above as truth. Whether it is truth or not depends on the formal meaning of the ellipsis ... which no one provides to me (I have asked several people about this). Without a formal definition, the statement is meaningless to me.

Here is a way to present it formally.

0.9999... is sum of a geometric series a + a * d + a * d^2 ... a * d^n ... with a = 0.9 and d = 0.1.

In the limit n -> infinity, the above sum is 1. This is however only true in the limit.

It is not clear/obvious to me that ... really means "in the limit".

Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by strangestchild on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @07:34PM (#5452623)
I agree with you that the ... notation is ill-defined. It's common in mathematics to use conventions that are a little woolly, but only where everyone understands how to express the idea more correctly.

Here's one way of presenting this formally. Define a 'decimal' to be an ordered sequence of integers (called 'digits') a_1, a_2, a_3, and so on. (By 'and so on', I formally mean that for each positive integer k we have a digit a_k at the kth position in the sequence). Let's say each a_k has to be between 0 and 9 inclusive.

For each positive integer k, define the 'kth partial sum' of the sequence to be the sum from j=1 to j=k of (1/10^j) x a_j.

I'll skip over what it means if we say that the partial sums converge as k->Infinity, because it sounds like you understand what limits are and how they work. If not, I'd be happy to explain.

Now, if the partial sums converge to some value 'd', we say that the decimal has value equal to d. It can be shown that any decimal has at most one such d (which is good, because a decimal shouldn't have two values).

Now, I think you'd be happy to say that when we write 0.9999999..., what we mean is the decimal where a_k=9 for all k. Given this definition, it follows that the value of the decimal is precisely 1, using properties of geometric sequences.

It is up to you how you define '...', but all mathematicians would agree that 0.99999... should be interpreted as above if it is to have any meaning at all.

If you really want a more precise eplanation of '...' at the end of a truncated decimal, I would provide the following: "Writing 0.abcdef... asserts that the digits abcdef of the truncation provided have a pattern which should be obvious to the reader. Assign the first few digits a_1, a_2 etc as per the part of the decimal that is explicitly given; and then assign all subsequent digits values according to said pattern." - it's not a formal notation, as I say, but rather a convenient shorthand that is understood by working mathematicians. It is always possible to be more precise if one has to be.

Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by lutusp on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @05:54PM (#5452242)
> Whether it is truth or not depends on the formal meaning of the ellipsis ... which no one provides to me (I have asked several people about this).

Mathematical definitions aren't like dictionary definitions. A closed ellipsis:

    1...100
Is accepted as meaning a list of all the intermediate values.

An open-ended ellipsis is accepted as meaning an infinite repetition of what precedes it. So this ellipsis:

    0.9999...
Means an infinite decimal sequence of 9's. And .999... really is equal to 1.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/0.999...

A quote: "In mathematics, the repeating decimal 0.999... (sometimes written with more or fewer 9s before the final ellipsis, or as 0.9, , 0.(9)) denotes a real number that can be shown to be the number one. In other words, the symbols "0.999..." and "1" represent the same number. Proofs of this equality have been formulated with varying degrees of mathematical rigor, taking into account preferred development of the real numbers, background assumptions, historical context, and target audience."

Remember that mathematics, like science, avoids ambiguity where possible. And mathematical notation strives for less ambiguity than mathematics itself.

Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by alok-g on Wednesday March 27, 2013 @06:29PM (#5452388)
Other than pointing to the Wikipedia article (thanks for the same), you have not said anything that I did not. The repetition of the decimals before the ellipsis is the same as the geometric series representation I mentioned. The Wikipedia article also mentions the limit in one of the proofs (though I am yet to read the other proofs there, which may be illuminating! :-)
Re:Controversial Facts In Mathematics by lutusp on Thursday March 28, 2013 @01:05AM (#5453406)
Mathematics isn't politics or law. The point is to come to a consensus on the meaning of symbols and conventions. The consensus is that the ellipsis in 0.999... extends out to infinity.

In mathematics, there is every incentive to agree on axioms like the meaning of the ellipsis. In science, there is every incentive to agree on the meaning of evidence and how it relates to theory. Only in psychology do they vote on the meaning of their "scientific" findings (all the new conditions that made their way into the new DSM got there by votes, not evidence) -- but psychology isn't a science, it's a pseudoscience.

Meanwhile, based on the agreed-upon axioms, 0.999... is equal to 1.