News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polycode – Open Source, cross-platform framework for game... by eropple on Tuesday March 26, 2013 @12:40PM (#5444427)
Unity is a great product for what it is, but it enforces upon you a particular view of the world and it's one I personally do not share. It puts you into its editor environment (which I don't find to be very good) and more or less expects you to be using the visual tools for most of what you're doing. I don't like that workflow; I prefer to work in a data-driven environment and in a real IDE. It is not as quick to prototype, but I enjoy it more and the end result satisfies me. I also prefer to know exactly what's going on in my game code, and there's enough obscuring that in Unity or another closed-source runtime that I'm not comfortable with it.

And I don't trust Unity not to close up shop one day and leave me high and dry with closed-source, bit-rotting libraries. Or to not target a platform I care about in the future, again leaving me screwed. I need to control the stack, and Unity is antithetical to this. (This is also why I have moved away from Xamarin's stuff--while enough of their stuff is open that I could spend multiple man-years re-implementing it if it went away tomorrow, it's a much better investment of my time to use the platform APIs directly.)

Re:Polycode – Open Source, cross-platform framework for game... by tolmasky on Tuesday March 26, 2013 @02:13PM (#5445060)
I was initially hesitant to use Unity or to give their workflow a chance, but now I have to admit I really love it. I use my own text editor vs. Monodevelop, and like a truly good visual editor, it really is just augmenting the code experience (you could do everything in code if you wanted). There really isn't that much magic going on.

That being said, I share many of your frustrations, but I think the root cause is that its closed source and not any particular design decision they made. At the end of the day the design is straight forward, but its hard to wrap your head around since you can't easily just look at the code and go "ah ok FixedUpdate gets called right after WhateverFunction, now this makes sense". This is severely exacerbated by bad documentation. Here is one of my favorite examples: http://docs.unity3d.com/Documentation/ScriptReference/Time-s... "Time.smoothedTime - A smoothed out Time.deltaTime (Read Only)." Great, no idea why I'd ever want this or what it actually does. In OS land I'd just go to the function, but not such option here.

On the other hand, I have considerable more faith in Unity than some OS tool to be around in the future and to support new platforms. They have a really great track record of this (they've been around forever), and the fact that they make money is more comforting to me than some random group of developers doing it for the love of programming. However, more tools is better, I'm in no way suggesting Polycode isn't cool or shouldn't exist or anything.

Re:Polycode – Open Source, cross-platform framework for game... by zerr on Friday April 05, 2013 @10:26AM (#5498595)
Could you please point me to the resources documenting "doing everything in code"?

For me, that tool based approach was a deal breaker, didn't care about it's closed source...