News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by paulgb on Thursday April 02, 2009 @08:12PM (#544264)
Apologies for being slightly off topic, but since there are a number of Atlas Shrugged readers here, I have a question:

Is it worth reading? Most discussion about the book seems to be about Objectivism in general, understandably. But aside from the philosophy of the book, is it an entertaining or interesting read? (or is that like the quotation asking "Otherwise, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the show?") I generally like to read books that are getting talked about, but I've heard so many mixed reviews of this it's a tough decision.

Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by Hast on Friday April 03, 2009 @11:54AM (#545048)
I think it's a better idea to read one of the shorter books first (IIRC the Fountainhead is pretty short). Atlas Shrugged could be cut down to about half the size and make the point it's trying to make better (by virtue of being more concise).

Personally I find it fascinating that the characters in the book (and Ayn Rand) constantly reiterate that "decisions should be made on logic and rationality instead of emotions" but the entire book is driven by pathos instead of any logical argument.

All the "good guys and gals" and smart, beautiful and horny. All the bad guys are ugly and stupid. They constantly use tautologies ("A is A") as if it was a way to debate with logic (it's not). And it never provides any attempt to prove that the entire premise is true or even feasible. Say what you want about Karl Marx but he did at least attempt to make a rational argument.

All that said you may still enjoy the book. Personally I've read a lot other books which make the same, or similar, point but better. Animal Farm springs to mind (no, it's not about objectivism, but it is about how power corrupts people, or animals).

Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by dantheman on Saturday April 04, 2009 @03:14PM (#546564)
The whole A is A thing is about reality and confronting it, very much like Nietzsche.
Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by unalone on Thursday April 02, 2009 @09:06PM (#544311)
The philosophy is mixed up in with it. I think it's an enjoyable book even if you don't agree with the philosophy.

Start with The Fountainhead, though. It's a much less flawed book, and it's less outright offensive.

Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by grandalf on Friday April 03, 2009 @03:41AM (#544633)
I recommend reading Atlas Shrugged first... the Fountainhead is a great book too, but not quite as good.

I suggest you download the unabridged audio version of Atlas Shrugged from audible.com or iTunes. It's read incredibly well and you'll probably enjoy it immensely...

Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by jibiki on Thursday April 02, 2009 @09:43PM (#544348)
It's a fun read, but it drags a bit towards the end. My gut feeling is that if you enjoyed Dune, then you would probably like Atlas Shrugged.
Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by chops on Friday April 03, 2009 @12:25AM (#544489)
I loved Atlas Shrugged (though it did take me a while to complete the speech), and coincidentally, I'm working on Dune right now, but I'm honestly struggling, and I haven't even reached page 100 yet.

It's just a little slow for me. Though having seen the movie and the miniseries, and knowing a fair bit of the Dune lore may be taking some of the "discovery" out of it.

Except for the speech, I didn't think Atlas Shrugged was slow at all, just LONG

Re:With 'Atlas Shrugged,' Hollywood may have its first anti-... by endtime on Thursday April 02, 2009 @10:48PM (#544414)
Read The Fountainhead first. It's a good primer for Atlas Shrugged, and it's a bit shorter, so if you hate it you'll save some time.