News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple forces each iOS app to have its own independent sys... by randall on Monday March 25, 2013 @01:31AM (#5435645)
>> "Does anyone benefit from this?"

Yes, users. Presumably, in Apple's view, the filesystem is a poor metaphor for users. Users think of their files as "in iTunes" or the like. Removing the filesystem separates concerns by requiring more strict ways of passing files around.

>> "each app must copy every file it needs access to" >> "Each and every developer must reinvent the file system"

These points are fair criticisms, but to claim blankly, "Apple needs to make a full U-turn on this" seems a bit much. I think there are a lot of potential fixes for this issue, and even though the author dismisses Dropbox, it seems like an obvious potential solution. There are other OS-level potentials though, like web intents, etc.

The claims, however, seem like a one-sided argument which fails to understand Apple's line of reasoning whatsoever.

Re:Apple forces each iOS app to have its own independent sys... by anigbrowl on Monday March 25, 2013 @02:52AM (#5435811)
It became such a pain in the ass for audio users that a new inter-app standard, AudioBus, was given the greenlight by Apple after accumulating signups from thousands of musicians who wanted to push audio & MIDI data between apps.
Re:Apple forces each iOS app to have its own independent sys... by coldtea on Monday March 25, 2013 @09:37AM (#5436857)
>It became such a pain in the ass for audio users that a new inter-app standard, AudioBus, was given the greenlight by Apple after accumulating signups from thousands of musicians who wanted to push audio & MIDI data between apps.

AudioBus doesn't have anything to do with sharing files on some folder. It's about passing audio and midi information around, which is different. You can do that, and still have every application perfectly isolated and deletable at will.

Re:Apple forces each iOS app to have its own independent sys... by anigbrowl on Monday March 25, 2013 @06:49PM (#5440231)
It arose partly because people were finding it such a hassle to move audio by saving it one app and opening it in another.
Re:Apple forces each iOS app to have its own independent sys... by coldtea on Tuesday March 26, 2013 @06:39AM (#5442283)
No, it arose because "saving audio in one and opening in another" is not how you work with sequences, plugins and effects in real time. You have to stream music and control data from one to another. It doesn't solve the "copy/paste audio from app to app" problem, it solves something totally different.

Obviously this is a problem that doesn't exist for most file types that don't have to be passed in real time between many apps to be manipulated at once (i.e almost all of them).