News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by rayiner on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:50PM (#5434849)
Lack of transparency is a huge issue. I remember when I started law school in 2009, the economy had just collapsed and we had zero information about how graduates were faring. The kind of stuff that's available today, at least from the better law schools, information detailing the precise number of students that went into which jobs, just didn't exist. For most schools it still doesn't.

That being said, the problem with law schools is just a microcosm of the problem facing higher education throughout the country. Skyrocketing tuition has meant that more and more of the lifetime increase in earning power obtained by a degree is being captured by schools. Indeed, these days for many people the net expected value is negative. But demand for higher education seems completely inelastic, largely perpetuated by the cultural myth that the way to improve our lot as a nation is for more education and better education. The fact of the matter is that more education isn't going to make well-paying middle class jobs come back from China, any more than it's going to break the cycle of poverty in inner city ghettos. It's just a smoke signal to justify ever increasing ranks of higher-paid teachers and professors.

Also, as ever, there are university administrators with their heads in the sand: "Sarah Zearfoss, senior assistant dean for admissions, financial aid, and career planning at the University of Michigan Law School, says law schools have growing increasingly aware of the major shift in the job landscape. 'We had not been doing anything different than other law schools,' she says, noting that graduates had gone on to prestigious private firms, nonprofits, and government jobs or clerkships. 'Our students were getting great jobs, but then the economy changed and we began to see some decline in offers.'"

The situation at the University of Michigan has declined from the point where nearly everyone could get a job justifying the almost $50k/year in tuition to the point where only 50-60% of the class can do so. That's the "new normal" and it's more than just "some decline."

Yes, people going to graduate school should be able to run the numbers, especially now that so much more information is out there, but in the face of administrators like these, is there any wonder why many choose to believe instead?

Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by jimktrains2 on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:11PM (#5434916)
> But demand for higher education seems completely inelastic, largely perpetuated by the cultural myth that the way to improve our lot as a nation is for more education and better education.

I wouldn't say that. I would say that the problem is by thinking a if you don't have a B[AS], you're worthless. Trade schools are, and will continue to be, important.

Mike Rowe sums it up in an address to congress: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0NwEFVUb-u0

Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by randomdata on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:54PM (#5435083)
I believe the parent's point is true. In my location (there is variance here), a graduate of a four year program needs to earn something like $43,000 per year to earn on par with a minimum wage worker without a post-secondary education when you consider the accumulated costs and lost opportunity.

The average income of a college graduate in my location is $34,000 per year. That means the majority of these graduates are effectively making less than minimum wage, yet the enrolment only continues to rise, if anything. That definitely seems inelastic to me.

Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by btilly on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:36PM (#5435291)
The average income of a college graduate in my location is $34,000 per year.

Source?

Is that average income across all jobs, or entry level jobs? Because there is an expectation that people coming out of college get low-paying jobs, and then see fairly rapid career advancement.

Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by Evbn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:59PM (#5435107)
Do run those numbers on a per-major basis, though. And try (though is is hard to get data) to separate the cohort who went to study and the cohort who went to party for 4 years.
Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by _delirium on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:09PM (#5435156)
There are also some issues around job preferences not being solely based on pay. The kinds of low-ish pay jobs worked by degree holders aren't identical to the distribution of low-ish pay jobs worked by non-degree holders, and skew, I believe, more office/white-collar rather than manual labor. Some people implicitly attach a significant value to that, whether due to working conditions or status, enough that they're willing to take that route even if they knew up front that it's not a net-positive financial decision. E.g., if attending college means you effectively make $10k/yr less, taking all costs into consideration, but you have a 60% greater chance of it being at a desk in an air-conditioned office, that might be worth it to some people.

In other words, some data on job-type mix rather than solely median salaries would be interesting.

Re:Law schools: Still hiding the sad truth from students by randomdata on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:08PM (#5435150)
I'm not sure where to even begin finding numbers for people working without a degree in the same field as the typical graduate of a given major to make the comparison, but I am definitely interested in seeing the results. My hunch says that we'll find very little difference between those with degrees and those without.

Unless you mean against minimum wage, but I'm not sure how telling that is. Certainly those with CS degrees will appear to be faring rather well, but that ignores that people without any degrees at all are doing just as well in the industry, and therefore are actually doing significantly better once you factor in the aforementioned costs.